Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2007 / iii / Paper 29 / 2 / b / Solution

A weight-$2k$ modular form gives an invariant tensor differentialbecause $d(\gamma \tau )=(c\tau +d{)}^{-2}d\tau$ cancels its automorphy factor. Assume first $k\ge 0$. At an ordinary quotient point this differential is holomorphic. At an elliptic point of order $e$, use $u$ and $w=u^e$ from part (a), and write the pullback as $A(u)(du{)}^k$, with $A$ holomorphic. Its invariance says $A(\zeta u){\zeta }^k=A(u)$, so a nonzero term $a_r{u}^r$ has $r+k\equiv 0(\mathrm{mod}e)$. Sincethe exponent in the descended coefficient is the integer $(r-k(e-1))/e$. With $r\ge 0$, it is at least $-\lfloor k(e-1)/e\rfloor$. At the modular cusp, $d\tau =dq/(2\pi iq)$ and $f$ has a power series with nonnegative exponents, so ${\omega }_f$ has a pole of order at most $k$.

Consequently the linear map $f\mapsto {\omega }_f$ injects $M_{2k}$ into the meromorphic sections of $K^{\otimes k}$ with poles bounded byThis section space is $H^0(X(1),K^{\otimes k}(D))$. It is finite-dimensional on a compact Riemann surface by the Riemann-Roch theorem. Concretely choose one nonzero meromorphic section of the line bundle; dividing by it identifies these sections with a Riemann-Roch space with a fixed finite divisor bound. This proves the requested finite-dimensionality by compact-surface theory.

In fact the injection is an isomorphism. If a descended coefficient has order at least $-\lfloor k(e-1)/e\rfloor$, its pulled-back exponent $ed+k(e-1)$ is nonnegative; the modular cusp pole bound likewise gives a holomorphic Fourier expansion of a modular form. These pullbacks therefore recover modular forms. Since $X(1)$ is the Riemann sphere, $\mathrm{deg}K=-2$, and a line bundle of degree $d$ on the sphere has $\max (0,d+1)$ sections. HenceFor negative $k$, the valence formula excludes a nonzero holomorphic modular form because all its orders would be nonnegative but their sum would be $k/6<0$; the space is zero. The mechanism behind finite-dimensionality is modular forms as meromorphic differentials on X(1), with explicit elliptic and modular cusp pole bounds.