Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2013 / iii / Paper 67 / 2 / a / Solution

Assume $0<ϵ\ll 1$ and $X,Y,\alpha =O(1)$. For $n=2$, use the method of multiple scales with $T=ϵt$ and complex amplitudesAt first order the forcing equations areThe product has frequencies $\pm 1,\pm 3$. Its $e^{it}$ coefficient is $\overline{A}B$, while it has no $e^{2it}$ coefficient. Removing the secular terms givesThe leading initial conditions give $A(0)=X/2$ and $B=Y/2$. Put $b=Y/2$, $A=p+iq$. The primary parametric resonance of a two-to-one oscillator pair is governed byFor $b^2>{\alpha }^2$, choose $\lambda >0$. Solving with $p(0)=X/2,q(0)=0$ yieldsIf $b^2<{\alpha }^2$, let $\nu =\sqrt{{\alpha }^2-b^2}/2$; replace $\cosh (\lambda T)$ by $\cos (\nu T)$ and $\sinh (\lambda T)/\lambda$ by $\sin (\nu T)/\nu$. On the boundary $b^2={\alpha }^2$, take the continuous limit:Thus exponential growth occurs when $|Y|>2|\alpha |$ and $X\ne 0$, on the scale $t=O({ϵ}^{-1})$. Equality is a marginal case that can produce linear slow growth: for $b=\alpha \ne 0$ the displayed initial phase excites it, whereas for $b=-\alpha$ it does not. If $X=0$, $x$ stays identically zero and the other oscillator is exactly uncoupled. The leading $y$ amplitude is constant; its backreaction is a higher-order effect on this time scale.

These are leading approximations for bounded slow time $T$, hence $t=O({ϵ}^{-1})$, while the amplitudes stay $O(1)$. First-order corrections can enforce the initial velocities exactly; the leading formula alone has an $O(ϵ)$ initial-velocity mismatch. In the unstable case the expansion must not be extrapolated through arbitrarily large amplification, where weak coupling and omitted terms cease to be uniform.

For $n=1$, both leading oscillations have frequencies $\pm 1$, so their quadratic product contains only frequencies $0,\pm 2$. There is no first-order resonant coupling: the solvability condition in the method of multiple scales gives $A_T=i\alpha A/2$ and $B_T=0$, a frequency shift without first-order amplitude growth. The constant and second-harmonic corrections can feed back into the fundamental at second order. Consequently the first possible growth scale from this second-order resonance from quadratic oscillator coupling isThis identifies the possible slow scale, not a guaranteed instability for every parameter or initial state. In particular, the first-order $\alpha$ frequency shift may detune the second-order resonance unless appropriately tuned; a second-order amplitude analysis would decide actual growth.