Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2014 / iii / Paper 43 / 3 / c / Solution

Assume $m\ne 0$, since the trivial $m=0$ theory cannot fix $\beta$ or the vacuum expectation value. A zero-energy vacuum must satisfy both $V=0$ and stationarity in both real scalar directions. With the notation from the preceding solution, these become $H=H_x=H_y=0$, because the prefactor $|m{|}^4{e}^{x^2+y^2}$ is positive. The derivatives areThese conditions also show that the zero-energy stationary point must be real. If $y\ne 0$, the second equation gives $P=(3-{\beta }^2)/2$; the first then gives $x=-({\beta }^2+3)/(2\beta )$. Substituting into the definition of $P$ gives $x^2+y^2=2$. Butwhich is impossible. Thus $y=0$, without assuming a real vacuum in advance.

Set $t=x+\beta$ and $F=1+xt$. Since $t=0$ would give $H=1$, it cannot occur. The zero-energy equation gives $F=s\sqrt{3}t$, $s\in \{1,-1\}$. Stationarity givesCombining these equations gives $1=(s\sqrt{3}-x)t=t^2$. Writing $t=\epsilon \in \{1,-1\}$ producesThe condition $\beta >0$ leaves exactly $(s,\epsilon )=(1,1)$ and $(-1,1)$. The second branch is a saddle point, as its real-direction curvature is negative; the stability calculation in the next solution verifies this explicitly. The stable zero-energy Polonyi vacuum therefore selectsZero energy alone, without stationarity and stability, would not imply this parameter value. Even zero energy plus stationarity also admits $\beta =2+\sqrt{3}$ on the unstable branch.