Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2014 / iii / Paper 70 / 2 / Solution

Use $F=F_s>0$ and constant entrainment parameter $\alpha >0$. The printed integrals are normalized by $\pi$, so a top-hat plume model has $Q=b^{2}w$, $M=b^2{w}^2$ and $F=b^{2}w{g}^{\prime }$; the physical area is still $\pi b^2$. Keeping this normalization avoids spurious factors of $\pi$ in the flux equations.

Eliminate height between the two flux balances. The plume flux-balance invariant follows fromsoFor positive fluxes, both $M$ and $Q$ increase. In particular $Q^{\prime }\ge 2\alpha \sqrt{M_s}>0$, so $Q\to \infty$ as $z\to \infty$. Therefore $C/(\lambda Q^2)\to 0$, whatever the finite source imbalance, and $M\sim {\lambda }^{2/5}{Q}^{4/5}$. Integrating $Q^{\prime }\sim 2\alpha {\lambda }^{1/5}{Q}^{2/5}$ gives the attracting similarity solutionThis proves attraction to pure plume similarity for physical positive source fluxes. Sources with a vanishing initial volume or momentum flux enter the positive regime immediately and can be obtained by the corresponding limiting solutions; a point buoyancy source has the same similarity form with zero virtual-origin offset. The statement assumes positive buoyancy flux: a jet with $F=0$ is a different asymptotic problem.

Define the plume balance parameterPure plume balance means $\Gamma =1$ at each height, or equivalently $C=0$: momentum, buoyancy and entrainment have their similarity relation, even when the source has finite radius. A forced plume has $\Gamma <1$, meaning excess momentum relative to this balance; a lazy plume has $\Gamma >1$, meaning insufficient momentum. The invariant ensures that the sign of the imbalance is preserved while $\Gamma \to 1$. In particular, a strictly positive source remains pure at every height precisely whenFor this source the exact solution is the same similarity form with $z$ replaced by $Z=z+z_0$. Writing $a=(9\alpha F_s/10{)}^{1/3}$,Thus the radius growth of an axisymmetric pure plume is $b^{\prime }=6\alpha /5$ and the plume virtual origin lies at $-z_0$, with $z_0=5b_s/(6\alpha )$. Equivalently, in terms of top-hat source properties, pure plume balance is $g_s^{\prime }{b}_s/w_s^2=8\alpha /5$.

For the stated source-to-source geometry, the relevant horizontal distance is $L_s$. Consequently the edge criterion is $b_m=L_s$, rather than the radius at which two expanding edges first touch. Since $b(z)=b_s+6\alpha z/5$,Here $b_s=Q_s/\sqrt{M_s}={\lambda }^{-1/5}{Q}_s^{3/5}$. A positive merging height requires $L_s>b_s$; equality puts it at the source, while an already wider source satisfies the geometric condition from the start. The no-interaction premise extrapolates independent plumes even though their edges would first touch earlier, when each radius is $L_s/2$.

Use $M^{5/2}=\lambda Q^2$ with $Q=b^{2}w$ and $M=b^2{w}^2$ to get $F_s=(8\alpha /5)b{w}^3$. The individual plume properties at the specified height are thereforeThe source volume flux affects the height through the virtual origin, but it does not affect these properties at a prescribed radius in an exactly pure plume.

For the stipulated merger of two equal pure plumes, the new radius is $b_c=\sqrt{2}{b}_m$. This factor is outside $b_m$, as required by the area. Since speed and reduced gravity are held fixed, the merged fluxes are $Q_c=2Q_m$, $M_c=2M_m$ and $F_c=2F_s$. Their balance parameter isThe immediate combined plume is lazy. The same result follows from $\Gamma =5g^{\prime }b/(8\alpha w^2)$: enlarging the radius at fixed $g^{\prime },w$ increases this parameter.

At fixed $w_m,g_m^{\prime }$, the radius required for pure plume balance isThat is half the stipulated combined area $2\pi L_s^2$. This fixed-speed pure-plume merger and flux conservation comparison exposes the limitation of demanding immediate pure balance with unchanged speed and reduced gravity: reducing the area to this value would also halve all three merged fluxes. A conservative merger must instead adjust its properties and begin out of pure balance. Under the given constant-entrainment equations, the resulting lazy plume subsequently approaches the attracting similarity solution with total buoyancy flux $2F_s$.