Past exam of the model theory and Gödel's incompleteness theorems course of the University of Oxford / 2007 / A / 3 / c

If $S⊢G$, theoremhood gives $S⊢\square G$, while the fixed-point equivalence also gives $S⊢\neg \square G$. Therefore first-order consistency implies $S⊬G$.

If $S\cup \{\neg G\}$ were inconsistent, the deduction theorem and classical propositional logic would give $S⊢\neg \neg G$, hence $S⊢G$. This is impossible by the preceding argument. ThereforeThis is a syntactic first-order consistency result. It does not claim that the extra axiom is true in the standard natural numbers or that the extended first-order theory is sound.