Past exam of the model theory and Gödel's incompleteness theorems course of the University of Oxford / 2010 / A / 1 / b / Solution

Again abbreviate provability by $\square$. The Gödel sentence equivalence gives $S⊢G\to \neg \square G$. Internalizing this implication using the first two Hilbert-Bernays-Löb derivability conditions givesPositive introspection also gives $S⊢\square G\to \square \square G$. Internal modus ponens rule combines proofs of a sentence and its negation into a proof of a contradiction; a contradiction implies any sentence. ConsequentlyThese are syntactic manipulations of provability, not an appeal to soundness. If $S⊢\neg \square \neg G$, taking the contrapositive of the last implication gives $S⊢\neg \square G$, and the diagonal equivalence gives $S⊢G$. Part (a) rules that out for a consistent theory. Hence