No. The prime-sign automorphism of the multiplicative integers from the preceding part sends the positive integer two to minus two. It therefore does not preserve the nonnegative integers, contradicting the necessary automorphism invariance of parameter-free definability. This also excludes definability of the strictly positive integers if that convention for the printed notation is used.
Past exam of the model theory course of the University of Oxford 2011 1 b ii γ Solution Created 2026-10-31 Updated 2026-11-05
No. Use the prime-sign automorphism of the multiplicative integerswhere is the exponent of two in , a p-adic valuation. For nonzero integers, , so ; the identity also holds when a factor is zero. The exponent of two is unchanged by changing the sign, hence . Thus is a multiplicative structure automorphism.