Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 27 4 b Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
We use dyadic quadratic variation of Brownian motion. For fixed rational , set and let be the sum of the squares of the Brownian increments on its equal-length partition. Independence and the normal fourth moment giveFor every , Chebyshev's inequality bounds by , a summable sequence. The Borel-Cantelli lemma implies almost surely. Intersect over positive rational and all rational intervals to obtain one probability-one event on which every such interval has this positive quadratic-variation limit.
If a path were Hölder of exponent on a nonempty open interval, choose a compact rational subinterval within it and a finite Hölder constant there. Every partition increment would have absolute value at most , soThis contradicts . The same pathwise event excludes every exponent greater than , without needing an uncountable intersection of events. ThereforeThis is the quadratic variation obstruction to Hölder regularity. It rules out a continuously differentiable trajectory on any interval, since a continuous derivative is bounded on smaller compact intervals and gives a Lipschitz bound. By itself it does not rule out differentiability at an isolated point. The stronger nowhere differentiability of Brownian motion can also be seen directly as follows.
On a mesh of width in , the probability that any specified three consecutive increments all have absolute value at most is at most : each increment is and the three are independent. There are at most possible blocks, so the probability of any such block is at most , summable in . By Borel-Cantelli lemma, for every pair of positive integers there are eventually no such blocks. But a finite derivative at some time would imply near . The three mesh increments beginning at the mesh point immediately to the left of would then all be at most for all sufficiently fine meshes. Choosing an integer contradicts the preceding event. Thus finite derivatives do not exist anywhere almost surely, including a finite right derivative at . The Hölder estimates below express continuity with a roughness scale; they do not imply differentiability.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 iii Paper 201 4 c Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
For every , its finite Hölder seminorm gives the deterministic boundWhen , the right-hand side tends to zero. Thus under any probability measure on the stated coordinate sigma-algebra, these measurable finite-coordinate sums converge to zero on every path, and hence almost surely.
If the coordinate process were a Brownian motion, part (b) would make the same sums converge to one in , and hence in probability. Almost sure convergence to zero also implies convergence in probability to zero. Uniqueness of a limit in probability is a contradiction. Therefore no such Brownian measure exists:This is the quadratic variation obstruction to Hölder regularity. It does not address the critical exponent , where the displayed deterministic bound does not tend to zero.