Prepare a fresh copy of the same quantum state for each trial and measure the same observable. If preparations and readouts are independent, the outcomes are independent and identically distributed random variables with the Born rule probability distribution. Their sample mean is an unbiased estimator of the expectation value:
The law of large numbers explains convergence of the sample mean, while the standard error describes its finite-sample spread. It takes four times as many independent trials to halve that standard error. This reduces estimation error; it does not reduce the quantum uncertainty of a single prepared copy.
For the spin expectation value, let and be the two outcome counts, with . Then
The binomial distribution gives the exact sampling model. For , the standard error is : approximately for and for . A run can fluctuate away from the predicted mean even as its typical spread decreases.
Figure 1.
Simulated running spin means and exact sample mean probabilities
. Original independent-trial model with . Left: four seeded simulated sequences of fresh preparations, with one-theoretical-standard error curves about . These curves are not simultaneous bounds on trajectories. Right: exact binomial distribution masses for the sample mean at and ; each set sums to one. The possible sample means become more closely spaced as increases. All points are simulations or calculations, not measured observations. Source. Details.
Repeatedly measuring one surviving system is a different protocol. Under the ideal Lüders rule, outcome leaves when . With no intervening change of observable or dynamics moving the state out of that eigenspace, the next projective measurement returns with certainty. Such a record is correlated and does not sample the original Born rule distribution independently. The quantum nondemolition measurement discussion describes this repeatability; fresh quantum state preparations supply the ensemble needed for the estimator above.
In the 2007 cavity quantum electrodynamics experiment of Christine Guerlin and collaborators, including Sébastien Gleyzes, Michel Brune, Jean-Michel Raimond and Serge Haroche, an injected coherent state occupied a 51.1 GHz microwave cavity with niobium-coated mirrors exhibiting superconductivity. Velocity-selected rubidium chemical atoms were prepared as circular Rydberg atoms in levels with principal quantum numbers 50 and 51. Repeated atomic readouts progressively narrowed the inferred photon number to a Fock state; later records revealed jumps. The cavity damping time was . Empty-cavity Ramsey interferometry scans fixed the analysis-phase origin; weak injected fields refined the response calibration. Finite fringe contrast required calibrated likelihoods; photon losses could interrupt convergence.[ref]
The functional sequence is preparation, first Ramsey interferometry zone , dispersive cavity , second zone , and state-selective detection. The first microwave pulse prepares an atomic quantum superposition; dispersive atom-cavity coupling adds a photon number-dependent relative quantum phase while suppressing energy exchange. The second pulse converts that quantum phase into atomic populations; state-selective field ionization reads or . Successive chemical atoms carry the meter records away while the same field remains available.[ref]
Figure 1.
Atoms carry photon-number information from the cavity to a detector
. Original functional schematic, not a scaled apparatus drawing. The atom is the meter; the final detector reads the atom. Details.
This arrangement makes quantum nondemolition measurement useful for following a field repeatedly and preparing a Fock state by conditioning. The photon number is inferred from a sequence of physical records; it is not a directly visible label attached to a photon. Each atomic probe makes a weak, partial measurement in quantum mechanics of photon number, and the accumulated records can approach a resolved count. A single binary meter need not identify one among many possible Fock states, as perfect discrimination of pure states requires orthogonality.
Lüders rule Created 2026-09-28 Updated 2026-10-14
The Lüders rule specifies the ideal quantum instrument for a projective measurement. Conditional on an outcome with nonzero probability, it gives
for a density operator and a pure state, respectively. The second formula applies only to a pure state input. If the result is discarded, the output is the nonselective projective measurement .
The crucial feature for a degenerate eigenvalue is preservation of quantum coherence within its eigenspace. For a qutrit with orthonormal basis , consider
On , outcome zero has probability one and the Lüders rule leaves unchanged. Measuring all three rank-one projectors and then forgetting whether the label was zero or one instead gives
Both procedures always report the coarse value zero, but a subsequent test with projector succeeds with probability one for the first and one half for the second. Resolving extra information destroyed coherence. This explains why a quantum nondemolition measurement of a degenerate quantity must specify what information the apparatus actually records.
Gerhart Lüders proposed this state-change rule in 1951, explicitly discussing degenerate quantities and distinguishing selected subensembles from the aggregate measured ensemble. Kirkpatrick's translation was first posted in 2004; equations (7) and (8) give the unnormalized selective update and the nonselective update. [ref].
Repeatability follows briefly from : after outcome , . This assumes a second application of the same ideal instrument without intervening dynamics. An instrument with the same effects can rotate or reset the output and need not satisfy this conclusion; see POVM does not determine the post-measurement state.
Interpret the requested measurement as distinguishing all four stated orthogonal eigenstates, hence as their rank-one projective measurement. If they have indistinguishable degenerate eigenvalues, this assumption need not hold; the identity observable, for example, cannot reveal the basis and gives no contradiction.
Let Bob initially prepare . Alice encodes a bit by preparing or , without changing Bob's initial reduced density matrix. If Alice prepares zero, the global input is the first eigenstate, so nondemolition leaves Bob in with certainty. If Alice prepares one, the rank-one Lüders rule, after discarding the outcome, dephases Bob in the rotated basis
His output is . A computational-basis measurement then gives
It is positive for every . Repeating the experiment would transmit Alice's choice across a spacelike interval, violating quantum no-signalling. The controlled-basis measurement causality obstruction therefore excludes the entire nonzero interval, including .
At , the basis is the computational product basis, up to an irrelevant sign on the fourth vector. Alice and Bob each measure locally, then compare their results later. Each product eigenstate is preserved. Thus being a product basis is insufficient for an instantaneous quantum nondemolition measurement: a remote party's choice of which local basis is measured can still cause signalling.
Write the system's basis as , and use a separate pair of meter qubits in the Bell state . Alice applies a CNOT gate from system to her meter qubit; Bob simultaneously applies a CNOT gate from to his meter qubit. Flipping neither or both meter qubits preserves , while flipping exactly one gives . Hence the entanglement-assisted nondemolition parity measurement interaction produces
where and . Each party now measures only their meter qubit in the basis. If their binary records are , the system Kraus operator is
Unequal records verify zero total spin, since vanishes precisely on the odd sector. The probability of success is , and the successful conditional state is . Every zero-total--spin state is left unchanged, including any coherent superposition of and . Similarly the even-sector coherence is preserved. This is a quantum nondemolition measurement of the parity, rather than separate measurements of both system spins.
All quantum operations and local meter measurements can finish within the spacelike time window. Nevertheless each local meter record is individually uniform: . The verification result is obtained only by comparing the records using local operations and classical communication. Thus “instantaneous” refers to the local completion of the joint measurement instrument, not instant access to its nonlocal outcome; quantum no-signalling remains intact.
Apply the modulo operation to the eigenvalues of . The product eigenstates have ordinary eigenvalues , respectively, and residues modulo . The resulting observable is
Use the entanglement-assisted nondemolition parity measurement from part (a). Equal local meter records give ; unequal records give . Its conditional quantum measurement maps are and , with normalization by their probabilities. The quantum nondemolition measurement preserves every vector within each degenerate eigenspace, including superpositions of and . Measuring the two system spins separately would destroy that even-sector coherence and would therefore not realize the same Lüders rule instrument. The nonlocal eigenvalue again becomes known only after local operations and classical communication compares the local records.
Sébastien Gleyzes Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-11-05
An experimental physicist who coauthored a quantum nondemolition measurement of cavity photon number. Atomic probes crossed the cavity one at a time; field-induced changes in their internal evolution revealed the stored field while preserving it for further probing.[ref]