Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 ia Paper 4 5E a Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
A left inverse of is a function satisfying . If such exists and , applying gives , so is an injection. Conversely, suppose is an injection and fix , possible because is nonempty. DefineThe first value is unique by injectivity, and for every . ThusNo choice from a family of nonempty sets is needed here: each preimage in the first case is unique, and the second case uses one fixed element.
A right inverse is a function with . Its existence makes every the image of , proving that is a surjection. Conversely, if is a surjection, every fiber of a function is nonempty. Using the usual axiom of choice for arbitrary sets, choose for each . Then , givingThe converse in this second equivalence is the right-inverse characterization of the axiom of choice; it is not an unrestricted choice-free theorem about arbitrary sets.