Integrating coaxial cylindrical shells gives
Rolling without slipping has spin speed , so .
For the rolling-cylinder loop contact threshold, set , the radius of the centre's circular path, and let run from the loop bottom. The centre starts above its lowest centre position. Its height gain from the bottom is . Energy conservation gives
At the top, contact requires , hence . Inserting the energy relation proves the limiting condition
The same condition keeps elsewhere on the circle, since
is smallest at the top.
For the centre's acceleration, the inward normal component is and the tangential component is . If and ,
This convex quadratic has its largest endpoint value at . The maximum on the circular loop is at the bottom, directed vertically upward. For the limiting release height,
The approach track's curvature is unspecified, so a global bound for an arbitrary approach shape cannot be proved from the sketch alone; the result above concerns the specified circular part and the usual smooth approach interpretation.
The finite-friction qualification of a marginal rolling loop also matters: the contact threshold presumes the stated no-slip idealization. At equality, near the top, required tangential friction vanishes linearly with angular distance from the top but vanishes quadratically. Thus any finite coefficient of static friction requires a release height above this limiting bound to maintain rolling everywhere; no coefficient is provided. This does not change the requested ideal contact criterion.