Past exam of the mathematical physics course of the University of Oxford 2007 B 8 ii Solution 2026-10-31
Put , use proper time , and denote its derivatives by dots. The timelike geodesic equations, away from the Schwarzschild coordinate singularity, arewith normalization . Spherical symmetry permits an equatorial plane, , and the cyclic coordinates give . Normalization then gives .
For and , . ThusAt , , the right side factors as . Set , so and . Integrating the regions and gives, up to angular shifts and time reversal,The constant , or , is the corresponding circular timelike orbit. The hyperbolic-tangent branch lies at and approaches that orbit from outside as ; the hyperbolic-cotangent branch lies at and approaches it from inside. Near the limit decays exponentially as . Since tends to , the limiting approach also takes infinite proper time. Neither nonconstant branch reaches and joins the circular orbit at a finite angular parameter.
Differentiating the orbit equation gives . A perturbation about obeys , showing that the circular orbit is unstable. The two explicit curves are its separatrix branches, not ordinary small stable oscillations. For the energy is marginally bound, so the outer critical branch is the limiting orbit between scattering and Schwarzschild marginally bound capture from infinity. Time-reversed inner and outer branches describe the corresponding approach or departure from that unstable orbit. These are the Explicit separatrices of the marginally bound Schwarzschild orbit.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 51 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Use geometrized units and metric signature ; is proper time. The Killing vectors and of the Schwarzschild metric give the conserved specific Killing energy and specific angular momentumPut . In the equatorial plane , and normalization of the four-velocity givesChoosing the inward branch therefore yieldsThe divergence of the time component at the Schwarzschild event horizon is a coordinate effect; the inward radial component tends to .
Capture from infinity. To reach the event horizon from infinity, the radial square must remain nonnegative throughout . Equivalently,Differentiating the right side gives , so its minimum occurs at and equals . Thusis the necessary capture bound. At equality the radial numerator is . An inward particle arriving from larger radii approaches the unstable orbit only after infinite proper time, because is proportional to near that orbit. Actual plunges from infinity require . This is Schwarzschild marginally bound capture.
The origin-at-infinity hypothesis is important and is not explicit in the PDF. A particle already inside the angular-momentum barrier can plunge with larger . For example, and initial radius give positive radial numerator , remaining positive as decreases to . This trajectory has and reaches the event horizon. Thus an unrestricted claim about every inward particle would be false; the bound is the intended capture-from-infinity statement.
Invariant collision energy. At a collision, the total four-momentum is . The invariant center-of-mass energy uses the covariant metric:The PDF instead prints a raised metric multiplying raised velocities. That contraction is not a tensor scalar; the corrected expression above, or a raised metric with lowered momenta, is required. Since each four-velocity has norm ,Let . For two inward trajectories the radial product is positive, and direct substitution into the Schwarzschild metric givesPutting these terms over one denominator proves
Horizon limit and the upper bound. A cancellation-free way to take the limit is to write and . As ,Henceand thereforeFor particles captured from infinity, , giving in the horizon limit. For actual captured trajectories the inequality is strict, but the supremum is approached by and . Their azimuthal starting positions can be chosen so that the trajectories meet. If particles may instead be prepared near the event horizon, the counterexample , has limiting energy ; no universal bound then follows.
Schwarzschild horizon collision energy 2026-10-07
For two equal-mass inward timelike geodesics of unit specific Killing energy, their invariant center-of-mass energy has this finite horizon limit. If both are captured from infinity, Schwarzschild marginally bound capture gives , with a supremum. No such universal bound follows for particles prepared inside the angular-momentum barrier.