Magnetic subcriticality of a razor-thin disk Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-11-05
Magnetic subcriticality refers to a mass-to-flux ratio below its critical mass-to-flux ratio. For an idealized thin layer threaded by a uniform frozen-in perpendicular magnetic field, define in SI unitsHere is the surface density and the perpendicular magnetic field. The magnetically subcritical case has , or . In the specified ideal layer, magnetic support prevents the linear gravitational collapse studied by Takenori Nakano and Takashi Nakamura. Their original Gaussian-unit threshold is . The numerical coefficient is tied to geometry and field assumptions.[ref]
Gravitational Instability of Magnetized Gaseous Disks by Takenori Nakano and Takashi Nakamura. Original abstract, perpendicular frozen-in field and critical column-density-to-field ratio
A complementary sufficient-contraction result applies to an isolated cold initially resting razor-thin disk. If pointwise, the absolute gravity-equivalent magnetic surface density is smaller than the actual surface density. The positive-kernel comparison of thin-disk fields then makes the integrand in the horizontal virial balance of a cold magnetized fluid negative above and below the disk. Its radial second moment therefore begins to decrease. This weak-field inequality is on the magnetically supercritical disk side of the mass-to-flux convention.
The second-moment conclusion is global. It does not establish inward acceleration of every fluid element, and it does not prove unlimited subsequent collapse. Pressure, rotation, magnetic flux loss and different boundary-field configurations require their own analysis.
Takashi Nakamura 2026-11-05
Takashi Nakamura, with Takenori Nakano, analyzed the gravitational instability of an isothermal gaseous disk threaded perpendicularly by a frozen-in magnetic field. Their 1978 linear stability analysis showed how magnetic support changes whether perturbations can collapse.[ref]
The competition is scale dependent: gas pressure stabilizes sufficiently short wavelengths, while the mass-to-flux ratio determines whether gravity can overcome magnetic support at larger scales.
Takenori Nakano 2026-11-05
Takenori Nakano investigated magnetic support against gaseous-disk collapse with Takashi Nakamura. For their 1978 thin-disk configuration with perpendicular frozen-in magnetic field, the critical mass-to-flux ratio isin Gaussian units, with surface mass density and field magnitude . Below the threshold, magnetic support prevents the modeled gravitational instability; gas pressure also suppresses short wavelengths.[ref]
Gravitational Instability of Magnetized Gaseous Disks by Takenori Nakano and Takashi Nakamura. Abstract: stability threshold and short-wave pressure support