The first algebra exists. Let with truncated convolution
The Tonelli theorem gives
Commutativity follows by replacing with ; associativity follows from the Fubini theorem applied to the simplex , . Together with completeness of , this makes a commutative Banach algebra, not necessarily unital. Adjoin an identity using unitization:
This norm is complete and submultiplicative by the preceding bound, and is the identity. This is the Volterra convolution algebra on a finite interval with an identity adjoined.
Take , where . Direct induction under convolution gives
Thus no power vanishes. For every the series
converges absolutely, since its norms have factorial denominators. Multiplication by telescopes to , so it is an inverse. On the other hand cannot be invertible: its scalar coordinate is zero, and scalar coordinates multiply, so can never equal . Hence
This explicitly exhibits a nonnilpotent quasinilpotent element without assuming a spectral-radius formula.
The second algebra does not exist. Suppose it did, and choose a nonscalar . Nonemptiness of its spectrum of an element, together with , gives . But is still nonscalar: if , then . By translation of the spectrum by a scalar,
This contradicts the required zero spectral radius for every nonscalar element. The contradiction already uses the spectral condition alone; the nonvanishing-power condition cannot remedy it.