Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2007 ib Paper 4 16E Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
For fixed endpoints, the Euler-Lagrange equation is . Since has no explicit dependence on , differentiating givesThus , the Beltrami identity.
With , the arc length element and the prescribed speed give the travel-time functionalFor the circular road , this is .
For the integrand , the Beltrami identity simplifies toThe candidate has and the required endpoints. To prove it really minimizes the travel time, rather than merely satisfies a first integral, put . ThenThis is the Euclidean arc length integrand for the inverted curve , whose endpoints are and . Every connecting curve has length at least their Euclidean distance , by the triangle inequality. Equality is attained by the straight line segment . In polar form it gives , hence the proposed . It stays strictly positive throughout the interval. ConsequentlyThis travel-time minimization with speed proportional to squared radius is globally solved by the inversion: its minimum is strictly less than .