Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 ia Paper 1 9E Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-06
The Bolzano-Weierstrass theorem states that every bounded sequence of real numbers has a convergent subsequence. We first use it to show that a continuous function on is bounded above. Otherwise, choose with . A convergent subsequence exists, with because the interval is closed. Continuity would give , contradicting .
Let , which is finite. By the definition of supremum, there are with . Another application of the Bolzano-Weierstrass theorem gives a subsequence . By continuity,Thus the supremum is actually attained:This proves the maximum part of the extreme value theorem from sequential compactness rather than assuming it.
Now suppose on . Applying the mean value theorem to shows that is strictly decreasing. At a local maximum of a differentiable function, the left difference quotients are nonnegative and the right difference quotients are nonpositive; existence of the derivative forces . A strictly decreasing function has at most one zero. ThereforeIf that zero exists, is positive to its left and negative to its right, so the local maximum is also a global maximum.
For the uniform bound by , defineIts derivative is , so is strictly decreasing by the mean value theorem. Comparing with givesBecause , this makes negative at sufficiently large positive and positive at sufficiently large negative . The function is continuous, since it is differentiable; the intermediate value theorem supplies a zero between such points. Its strict decrease makes this zero unique. Again using the mean value theorem for , the derivative signs imply that increases up to and decreases after :This illustrates uniform negative curvature and global maximization.
Merely requiring does not force existence. TakeThen and , but is strictly increasing, approaches as , and never equals . The answer to the final question is no, even for a function bounded above:The stronger uniform curvature assumption prevents this behaviour. Here at the end where the supremum is approached, so no uniform negative bound of that kind is available.