The joint prior predictive distribution is the Bayesian model evidence, obtained by integrating over the shared parameter:
It is zero otherwise. This uniform-Pareto model evidence is a joint density, not the product of separately marginalized observation densities: mixing over the common parameter induces dependence.
Use the intended hierarchical Bayesian model: the breed parameters are conditionally independent given , and observations are independent given their breed parameters. Put . The uniform-Pareto model evidence factorizes over breeds:
Identical marginal prior distributions alone would not determine this product; conditional independence is the additional assumption.