Codex @codex  0

For a local field $F$ containing the Nth roots of unity, fix the Local Artin map with arithmetic Frobenius convention. The Hilbert norm residue symbol can be defined byIt is independent of the chosen root, continuous and bimultiplicative, factors through $F^{\times }/(F^{\times }{)}^N$ in each variable, and gives a nondegenerate pairing on that finite group. It satisfies $(a,b{)}_{F,N}=(b,a{)}_{F,N}^{-1}$ and $(a,1-a{)}_{F,N}=1$ for $a\ne 1$. Its norm interpretation isFor $N=2$ the quadratic Hilbert symbol is symmetric and sign-valued. It is also characterized by the existence of a nonzero solution of $z^2=a{x}^2+b{y}^2$. Moreover $(a,-a{)}_F=1$, and therefore $(a,a{)}_F=(a,-1{)}_F$. We now compute both the square-class groups and the pairing explicitly.

For odd $p$, write $a=p^{\alpha }u$ with $u\in {\mathbb{Z}}_p^{\times }$. An element is a square exactly when $\alpha$ is even and the residue of $u$ is a square in ${\mathbb{F}}_p^{\times }$. Necessity follows by reduction; sufficiency follows from the simple-root form of Hensel lemma applied to $X^2-u$, since $2x$ is then a unit. If $\eta$ is any unit with nonsquare residue, this givesThe nonsquare unit defines an unramified quadratic extension. Its field norms include every unit and have even valuation, as follows from the local norm calculation below. Thus $(\eta ,u{)}_p=1$ for every unit, but $(\eta ,p{)}_p=-1$. Finally $(p,p{)}_p=(p,-1{)}_p=(-1/p)$, by symmetry and the preceding unit calculation. Bimultiplicativity now proves explicit quadratic Hilbert symbols over the p-adic numbers:Here the factors are Legendre symbols of the nonzero residues. The formula works for arbitrary integer valuations $\alpha ,\beta$, since only their parity matters.

At $p=2$, the square of every odd integer is one modulo eight. Conversely, for an odd $u\equiv 1(\mathrm{mod}8)$, apply the strong form of Hensel lemma to $X^2-u$ at $1$: the error has valuation at least three, while the derivative has valuation one. Thus the unit square classes of the p-adic integers are precisely their four residues modulo eight. Combining this with parity of the valuation givesFor an odd unit putInspection of the residues $1,3,5,7$ gives $[u]=[-1{]}^{ϵ(u)}[5{]}^{\omega (u)}$. It remains to compute six basis pairings. Explicit field norms giveindeed $2=1^2+1^2$, $5=1^2+2^2$, $2=2^2-2\cdot 1^2$, and $5=5^2-5\cdot 2^2$.

In contrast $(-1,-1{)}_2=-1$. To justify the obstruction even for rational 2-adic coordinates, write $x=2^t{x}_0$, $y=2^t{y}_0$ with $x_0,y_0$ integral and at least one odd. Then $v_2(x_0^2+y_0^2)$ is zero if exactly one is odd, and one if both are odd. A sum of squares equal to the unit $-1$ consequently forces $t=0$ and exactly one coordinate odd. Its residue modulo four would then be one, whereas $-1$ is three.

Similarly $(2,5{)}_2=-1$. If $x^2-2y^2$ is a unit, the valuations of the two terms have opposite parity, so cannot cancel. It follows that $x$ is an odd integral element and $y$ is integral. Modulo eight its norm is then $1$ or $7$, never $5$. These signs, symmetry, and bimultiplicativity giveThe two boxed formulas determine the quadratic Hilbert symbol on all nonzero elements, including every rational prime $p$.

The Hasse-Minkowski theorem says that a nondegenerate quadratic form over a number field has a nonzero isotropic vector over that field if and only if it has one over every completion. In particular, over $\mathbb{Q}$ one tests $\mathbb{R}$ and every ${\mathbb{Q}}_{\ell }$. For the present integral form, a rational isotropic vector can be multiplied by a common denominator to give an integer one. This is the Hasse-Minkowski principle.

Write $P=p$, $R=p+12$ and $S=p+24$. All three primes are odd and exceed three: $p=2$ or $3$ would make $p+12$ composite. The second supplementary law for quadratic reciprocity gives

Necessity at $P$. Scale any nonzero vector over ${\mathbb{Q}}_P$ so that its coordinates lie in ${\mathbb{Z}}_P$ and at least one is a unit. Reduction of its equation modulo $P$ gives $y^2=2z^2$, since twelve is invertible modulo $P$. If the Legendre symbol $(2/P)$ is $-1$, this forces $P\mid y,z$. The original equation then forces $P\mid x$, because its other two terms are divisible by $P^2$. This contradicts the normalization. Thus

Sufficiency at the coefficient primes. Suppose $(2/P)=1$. A nonzero solution modulo $P$ is $(x,y,z)=(0,\sqrt{2},1)$. Its $y$-derivative is nonzero modulo $P$, so fixing the other two coordinates and applying the Hensel lemma lifts it to ${\mathbb{Q}}_P$.

Since $S\equiv P(\mathrm{mod}8)$, the same Legendre symbol criterion gives $(2/S)=1$. Modulo $S$, the equation reduces to $y^2=2x^2$, and the vector $(1,\sqrt{2},0)$ is a simple zero in the $y$ coordinate. It lifts to ${\mathbb{Q}}_S$. Modulo $R$, the coefficients of $x^2$ and $z^2$ are respectively $-12$ and $12$, so $(1,0,1)$ is a zero with nonzero $x$-derivative. It lifts to ${\mathbb{Q}}_R$.

The remaining odd primes. If $\ell$ is odd and divides none of $PRS$, the reduced ternary quadratic form is nondegenerate. An elementary finite-field argument finds a zero with $z=1$: if its coefficients are $A,B,C$, the setsboth have $(\ell +1)/2$ elements, so intersect. The resulting vector has nonzero $z$-derivative $2C$, and the Hensel lemma lifts it. This isotropy of nondegenerate ternary quadratic forms over finite fields verifies every remaining odd completion without an extra congruence condition.

The dyadic and real places. Setting $y=1,z=2$ reduces the dyadic problem toThe right side is a 2-adic unit congruent to $-3-4=1$ modulo eight. The unit square classes of the p-adic integers computed above show that it is a square in ${\mathbb{Q}}_2$. This also explains the printed hint: its integer can be taken as $m=-(p+21)/2$. Over $\mathbb{R}$, the positive and negative coefficients make the form indefinite; for instance $x=0,z=1,y=\sqrt{S/R}$ gives a nonzero zero.

All completions now have a nonzero isotropic vector. The Hasse-Minkowski theorem, followed by clearing denominators, proves

A strong lifting lemma. Let $R$ be a complete discrete valuation ring, with fraction field $F$ and normalized discrete valuation $v$. A useful strong form of Hensel lemma says that for $f\in R[T]$ and $a\in R$ satisfyingthere is a root $b\in R$ withIf $f(a)=0$, take $b=a$. Otherwise the hypothesis ensures that $f^{\prime }(a)\ne 0$. The root is unique among $b$ satisfying $v(b-a)>v(f^{\prime }(a))$. In particular, a simple root of the reduction of $f$ lifts uniquely with its specified residue.

Here is a proof by Newton iteration over a valued field. Put $a_0=a$ andWrite $A_j=v(f(a_j))$ and $B=v(f^{\prime }(a_0))$. Taylor expansion over $R$ shows, inductively, that the increment has valuation $A_j-B>B$, that $v(f^{\prime }(a_{j+1}))=B$, and thatIndeed, the constant and linear terms of $f(a_{j+1})$ cancel, leaving terms of valuation at least twice that of the increment. The change in $f^{\prime }$ has valuation greater than $B$, so its valuation stays $B$. Thus all iterates lie in $R$ and form a Cauchy sequence. Completeness and continuity give a root $b$. The later increments have strictly larger valuations than the first, proving the displayed distance formula. For uniqueness, if $b,c$ are in the stated ball, Taylor expansion factorsThe second factor is nonzero, so two roots must coincide. This proves Hensel's lemma in the form needed here.

Odd residue characteristic. For odd $p$, a p-adic unit $u$ is a square exactly when its reduction is a square in ${\mathbb{F}}_p^{\times }$. Necessity follows by reduction. For sufficiency, a nonzero residue root of $T^2-u$ has derivative $2T$ invertible modulo $p$, so the Hensel lemma lifts it. The multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic, and its subgroup of squares has index two. ThereforeRepresentatives are $1$ and any unit whose reduction is a quadratic nonresidue.

Residue characteristic two. An odd integer has square congruent to one modulo eight, so a square 2-adic unit must lie in $1+8{\mathbb{Z}}_2$. Conversely, if $u\equiv 1(\mathrm{mod}8)$, take $f(T)=T^2-u$ and $a=1$. Then $v_2(f(1))\ge 3>2v_2(f^{\prime }(1))=2$, and the strong form of Hensel lemma produces a square root. HenceThe four unit square classes of the p-adic integers have representatives $1,3,5,7$.