Vortex charge neutrality (${\sum }_x{q}_x=0$)

For the Villain model on a periodic two-dimensional lattice, the vortex charge is the oriented curl of its integer bond variable. Summing over all faces cancels every bond twice, proving neutrality. In an infinite plane, a configuration with net winding $Q$ has far-field spin wave action $\pi \beta Q^2\log (L/a)$, so finite-energy localized configurations must have $Q=0$. At an open boundary the total winding instead equals the boundary circulation; neutrality cannot be imposed without a boundary condition.