Past exam of the atmospheric physics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 Paper 1 2 b Solution 2026-10-20
Warm-rain growth: condensation first creates cloud droplets, but its approximate growth narrows relative size differences and becomes inefficient at making large raindrops quickly. A broadened size spectrum lets larger, faster-falling drops collect smaller ones by collision-coalescence. The cloud-droplet collision kernel combines collection efficiency and differential settling. Turbulence, sufficient cloud depth and liquid-water content determine whether collector drops grow rapidly enough. Collisions must actually lead to merging rather than bypass, bounce or breakup.
Ice-phase growth: in a mixed-phase cloud, equilibrium vapour pressure over ice is lower than over supercooled liquid. Ice can grow by deposition while droplets evaporate: the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. Ice particles then grow further by riming of supercooled droplets and by ice-crystal aggregation. They may fall as snow or melt into rain. Deposition, riming and aggregation are distinct processes; depositing vapour alone need not complete precipitation growth.
Precipitation efficiency depends on the supply of suitable collector drops or ice, residence time, updraft speed, supersaturation and collection/sticking efficiencies. Competition among too many small particles can inhibit growth, and evaporation or sublimation below the cloud can prevent condensate from reaching the surface. Both pathways require growth and fall-out to compete successfully with these losses. [ref]
International Cloud Atlas by World Meteorological Organization. Glossary: accretion, aggregation, coalescence; snow as single or aggregated ice crystals
Past exam of the atmospheric physics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 Paper 1 2 b Solution 2026-10-20
Warm-rain pathway: condensation first grows activated droplets, but its relative size growth slows. A sufficiently broad size spectrum creates different fall speeds; large drops collect smaller ones by collision-coalescence. Collection efficiency, turbulence, liquid-water supply and residence time control the bottleneck. Rain reaching the ground also requires survival against subcloud evaporation.
Ice pathway: below freezing, saturation vapour pressure over ice is lower than over supercooled liquid. In mixed-phase air, ice can grow by deposition while droplets evaporate: the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. Ice also collects droplets by riming and combines by aggregation. Adequate ice nuclei, sustained supersaturation and residence time are critical; particles must become heavy enough to fall, with snow sometimes melting to rain. Condensation or deposition alone is not generally sufficient for rapid precipitation.
The target liquid-water mass isThe thin-plate ice-growth time uses the prescribed ice mass law, which therefore requires , not the same radius as the water droplet. With and ,Hence, for negligible seed mass and constant conditions,This is about times faster than the liquid estimate to the same mass. Both laws have under the given shape assumptions. Ice benefits here from five times the atmospheric supersaturation and a larger geometrical capacitance for the same mass, partly offset by its slightly greater transport resistance. The mass coefficient encodes the assumed plate shape; replacing it by bulk ice density would change the supplied model.
In a mixed-phase cloud, saturation vapour pressure over ice is lower than over supercooled liquid water. Air can therefore be subsaturated with respect to liquid yet supersaturated with respect to ice: droplets evaporate while ice crystals grow, transferring water through the vapour phase. This is the Wegener–Bergeron–Findeisen mechanism. Subsequent aggregation, riming and melting can produce atmospheric precipitation much faster than condensation alone.
The large difference is not a universal fixed ice/liquid time ratio. Atmospheric supersaturation evolves, latent heating increases thermal resistance, crystal habits and capacitance change, and surface attachment or ventilation may matter. Ice nucleation and the availability of freezing nuclei also precede the calculated growth. The boxed time describes the specified already-present crystals under maintained conditions, not a complete prediction of the time until rain begins.