JavaScript memory usage benchmark

New to topics? Read the documentation here!

Top articles Latest articles New article in topic

Show body

Ciro Santilli 34 Updated 2024-11-19 Created 1970-01-01

In this section we will use the file nodejs/bench_mem.js, tests are run on Node.js v16.14.2 from NVM, Ubuntu 21.10, on Lenovo ThinkPad P51 (2017) which has 32 GB RAM.

First using topp from stackoverflow.com/questions/1221555/retrieve-cpu-usage-and-memory-usage-of-a-single-process-on-linux/40576129#40576129 let's observe the memory usage of some baseline cases.

A C hello world with an infinite loop at the end has:

2.7 MB
770 KB

For a Node.js infinite loop nodejs/infinite_loop.js

topp infinite_loop.js

This gives approximately:

RSS: 20 MB
VSZ: 230 MB

Adding a single hello world to it as in nodejs/infinite_hello.js and running:

topp infinite_hello.js

leads to:

RSS: 26 MB
VSZ: 580 MB

We understand that Node.js preallocates VSZ wildly. No big deal, but it does mean that VSZ is a useless measure for Node.js.

Forcing garbage collection as in nodejs/infinite_hello.js brings it down to 20 MB however:

topp node --expose-gc infinite_hello_gc.js

Finally let's see a baseline for process.memoryUsage nodejs/infinite_memoryusage.js:

node --expose-gc infinite_memoryusage.js

which gives initially:

{
  rss: 23851008,
  heapTotal: 6987776,
  heapUsed: 3674696,
  external: 285296,
  arrayBuffers: 10422
}

but after a few seconds randomly jumps to:

{
  rss: 26005504,
  heapTotal: 9084928,
  heapUsed: 3761240,
  external: 285296,
  arrayBuffers: 10422
}

so we understand that

heapUsed seems constant at 3.7 MB
heapTotal is a very noisy, as it starts at 7 MB, but randomly jumps to 9 MB at one point without apparent reason

Now let's run our main test program.

First a baseline case with an array of length 1:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js n 1

This gives the same results as node --expose-gc infinite_memoryusage.js. The same result is obtained by doing:

a = undefined

with:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js dealloc

Not let's vary the size of n a bit with:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js n N

which gives:

N	`heapUsed`	`heapTotal`	`rss`	`heapUsed` per elem	`rss` per elem
1 M	14 MB	48 MB	56 MB	10	30
10 M	122 MB	157 MB	176 MB	18	15
100 M	906 MB	940 MB	960 MB	9	9.3

"rss per elem" is calculated as: rss - 26 MB, where 26 MB is the baseline RSS seen on n 1.

Similarly "heapUsed per elem" deduces the 4 MB (approximation of the above 3.7 MB) seen on n 1.

Note that to reach MAX_SAFE_INTEGER we would need 8 bytes per elem worst case.

Everything below 100 million (8) is therefore very memory wasteful in terms of RSS.

If we use Int32Array typed array buffers instead of a simple Array:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js array-buffer n N

we see that the memory is now, unsurprisingly, accounted for under arrayBuffers, e.g. for N 1 million:

{
  rss: 31776768,
  heapTotal: 6463488,
  heapUsed: 3674520,
  external: 4285296,
  arrayBuffers: 4010422
}

Results for different N:

|| N
|| `arrayBuffers`
|| `rss`
|| `rss` per elem

| 1 M
| 4 MB
| 31 MB
| 5

| 10 M
| 40 MB
| 67 MB
| 4.6

| 100 M
| 40 MB
| 427 MB
| 4

We see therefore that typed arrays are much closer to what they advertise (4 bytes per element), even for smaller element counts, as expected.

Now let's try one million objects of type { a: 1, b: -1 }:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js obj

gives:

{
  rss: 138969088,
  heapTotal: 105246720,
  heapUsed: 70103896,
  external: 285296,
  arrayBuffers: 10422
}

Disaster! Memory usage is up to 70 MB! Why?? We were expecting only about 24, 4 baseline + 2 * 10 for each million int?!

And now an equivalent version using class:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js class

gives the same result.

Let's try Array:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js arr

is even worse at 78 MB!! OMG why.

{
  rss: 164597760,
  heapTotal: 129363968,
  heapUsed: 78117008,
  external: 285296,
  arrayBuffers: 10422
}

Let's change the number of fields on the object? First as a sanity check:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js obj 2

produces as expected the smae result as:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js obj

so adding properties one by one doesn't change anything from creating the literal all at once. Good.

Now:

node --expose-gc bench_mem.js obj N

gives heapUsed:

1: 70M
2: 70M
3: 70M
4: 70M
5: 110M
6: 110M
7: 110M
8: 134M
9: 134M
10: 134M
11: 158M

Read the full article