Preserving synchronous gauge means keeping both and zero. Applying the metric transformation to the background gives
The first equation requires , so . For the scalar displacement , the second requires , up to a spatially homogeneous coordinate displacement that does not affect scalar perturbations. Integrating gives
This is the residual gauge freedom in synchronous gauge. The lapse and shift conditions do not uniquely choose a slicing and spatial labeling.
A background density is a scalar, so under this remaining time displacement
For a fluid with constant equation of state, background conservation gives , hence
The synchronous density gauge mode scales as in radiation domination and as in matter domination. It can mimic a changing density perturbation without changing physical observables. A density time dependence alone therefore does not identify a physical growing or decaying mode. Choosing coordinates comoving with cold matter fixes the residual time freedom, and a remaining spatial relabeling fixes the initial metric-trace integration convention. Gauge-invariant curvature perturbations provide another way to specify physical initial conditions.
For consistency, linear metric theory requires all background-orthonormal components of to be small. The PDF's small-determinant condition by itself is insufficient: has zero determinant even for large . This is small determinant does not imply a small metric perturbation.
Let be the normal acceleration. It is tangential by normalization. Resolving the derivative's first index into normal and tangential parts gives
The extrinsic curvature is symmetric because the normal is hypersurface orthogonal: locally , and the antisymmetric derivative of vanishes after projecting both indices tangentially.
Apply the supplied Ricci commutator to and project its free index. With the positive-expansion convention it gives
To identify the first two terms, expand the fully projected divergence:
Tangency gives . Differentiating it shows that the last term is . Substituting into the commutator proves the contracted Codazzi equation with positive expansion:
No assumption of geodesic normals was needed; the acceleration terms cancel rather than being discarded.
The metric-trace term in the Einstein field equations drops out of a tangential-normal projection, since . Define the normal-frame momentum density . The equation becomes
Thus Codazzi supplies the momentum constraint on each spatial slice. In flat homogeneous FRW, and has no spatial gradient, so its left side vanishes. A comoving homogeneous perfect fluid likewise has . The background satisfies the constraint automatically; the Friedmann expansion law is instead obtained from the normal-normal constraint.
Suitable scalar variables are lapse and shift potentials , spatial curvature and scalar shear potentials , and a matter momentum potential with . For example, choose
A density contrast and pressure perturbation can be added for the remaining scalar matter equations. With this positive-shift convention, the linear extrinsic-curvature perturbation is
Its scalar shear cancels out of the momentum-constraint combination, leaving
These are the scalar momentum constraint with positive extrinsic curvature variables; a specified gauge can then remove two of the four scalar metric potentials.
Write for the induced metric. The spatial covariant derivative projects its derivative index and both tensor indices:
Four-dimensional metric compatibility removes the derivative of . Each remaining term contains an undifferentiated normal on a projected index and hence vanishes. Therefore
This establishes metric compatibility of the spatial covariant derivative directly from its projected definition.
Differentiating the normal's normalization gives
so . Consequently the second projection in the extrinsic curvature definition is redundant:
Finally differentiate and project:
The first term vanishes by , and the second is precisely the defining curvature. The positive sign follows from the specified positive-expansion convention, rather than from an independent projector convention.
Use for the conformal expansion rate and for the physical Hubble parameter. A future unit normal to a constant- slice is
It has norm minus one, and the spatial projection tensor is . The nonzero connections needed here are , and . Thus . Projection removes every normal component, yielding
This uses the positive-expansion convention for extrinsic curvature in the question. With the alternative convention that inserts an overall minus sign, all these extrinsic-curvature quantities change sign.
For a comoving cell, the physical volume is proportional to . Its logarithmic derivative in proper time is . Thus the trace is the expansion rate of the normal congruence: positive for expansion and negative for contraction. The isotropic tensor has vanishing trace-free shear. It measures homogeneous expansion, not the intrinsic spatial curvature, which is zero in this flat model.
Classically, the laws of thermodynamics and black-hole thermodynamics have parallel structures, but an ordinary black hole absorbs and does not emit: its temperature would appear to be zero, despite nonzero surface gravity. Hawking radiation changes this by giving an actual temperature measurable from a thermal particle spectrum. In units ,
Scattering through the exterior modifies the observed flux by greybody factors; for rotation and charge the occupation involves . These transmission and chemical-potential factors do not change the underlying Hawking temperature.
The Zeroth law of black-hole mechanics makes constant on a stationary horizon, so it gives a uniform equilibrium temperature, matching the zeroth law of thermodynamics. The full First law of black-hole mechanics is
Comparing it with and using the actual Hawking temperature fixes
With constants restored, . If is defined geometrically with dimensions of inverse length, ; if surface gravity is expressed as an acceleration, the equivalent formula is . The first-law comparison fixes entropy up to an additive constant. This is the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, so the mechanical analogy becomes a quantitative thermodynamic identification, including its normalization.
The classical second law of black-hole mechanics then corresponds to increasing black-hole entropy. Quantum evaporation can reduce , because the classical energy-condition hypotheses fail, while outgoing radiation carries entropy. The appropriate thermodynamic statement is the generalized second law,
Finally, the third law of black-hole mechanics, that zero surface gravity cannot be achieved by a finite physical process under its regularity assumptions, becomes the unattainability of zero temperature. It does not assert the Nernst entropy formulation: an extremal horizon can have nonzero area. Hawking radiation supplies the physical temperature, the first law fixes entropy, and the generalized second law includes both the black hole and its exterior matter.
Use a real free Klein-Gordon field on a prescribed four-dimensional globally hyperbolic spacetime, with signature and . A mass and curvature coupling give the quadratic action
and the field equation . Minimal coupling is ; for a massless scalar in four dimensions, conformal coupling is . Global hyperbolicity supplies a Cauchy hypersurface and a well-posed initial-value problem: suitable data on determine a unique solution. One assumes appropriate support or decay conditions so no unaccounted flux crosses spatial infinity. The geometry is classical here; quantum backreaction is a further problem.
The real solution space has the conserved symplectic form on scalar-field solutions
Its complexification defines the Klein-Gordon inner product
The divergence of its current is by the field equation, proving independence of the chosen Cauchy hypersurface. This Hermitian form is not positive definite on the whole complex solution space: conjugating a solution reverses its norm.
Choose a complete positive-norm mode space and basis satisfying
Here completeness means that every real solution expands in these modes and their conjugates. Equivalently, one chooses a compatible complex structure on the Klein-Gordon solution space; this is extra data, not fixed by the field equation. Quantization replaces the mode coefficients by annihilation operators and creation operators:
In a foliation with induced metric determinant , the canonical momentum is . The normalized complete mode expansion implements the equal-time canonical commutation relations and vanishing field-field and momentum-momentum commutators on . Propagation by the field equation gives microcausality: field observables commute at spacelike separation. Thus there is a local quantum field theory before one has selected a particle interpretation.
The chosen positive-mode space completes to a one-particle Hilbert space . Its bosonic Fock space is . The Fock vacuum obeys ; acting with produces multiparticle states, and counts particles in mode . The vacuum two-point function is . The Hadamard condition restricts physically admissible states by prescribing their local short-distance singularity; it permits renormalization of the stress-energy tensor but does not select one unique vacuum.
The particle ambiguity is that there is generally no distinguished choice of positive-mode space. A second complete normalized basis can be
The Bogoliubov transformation preserves the mode normalization precisely when
Its operators obey . Consequently a state with no -particles generally has -particles if . A unitary change of basis within the same positive-mode space has and merely relabels modes; a change mixing the positive and negative subspaces changes the vacuum and particle notion. Arbitrary coordinates called “time” do not resolve this choice. This is the vacuum ambiguity in a nonstationary spacetime, while the field equation and local commutator remain unchanged.
In the standard stationary setting, a complete future-directed timelike Killing vector field generates a time-translation symmetry. With a stable positive energy operator and suitable boundary conditions, choose positive-frequency solutions by
The positive stationary Hamiltonian selects a particle splitting: positive spectral modes define annihilation operators, and the normal-ordered Hamiltonian is . Its ground state is the vacuum state in a stationary spacetime. The Killing symmetry transports this splitting unchanged, so no positive-negative mixing is induced by stationary evolution. Degeneracies allow unitary basis changes without changing the vacuum. Stationarity fixes the ground-state particle interpretation relative to this time flow; it does not forbid excited or thermal states.
The qualification is that asymptotic stationarity alone, in the sense used for a Kerr exterior, is insufficient for a global positive-energy construction: becomes spacelike in an ergoregion of a stationary spacetime. The usual unambiguous construction applies to a strictly stationary spacetime with the stated stability and spectral assumptions, or to appropriate stationary asymptotic regions for scattering. Zero modes or instability need separate treatment. Likewise different observer time flows on different regions need not define the same particles.
For particle creation by a nonstationary spacetime, choose normalized positive-frequency modes in the stationary early region and in the stationary late region. Propagate both sets by the Klein-Gordon equation through the intermediate time-dependent geometry. Compute their overlaps on any common Cauchy hypersurface:
The initial in-vacuum has . Since , contracting the in operators yields the particle number from Bogoliubov coefficients:
Thus the procedure is to fix asymptotic mode choices, solve the classical wave equation, project using the conserved inner product, and take squared negative-frequency overlaps. Particle energy comes from the time-dependent background, so particle creation does not contradict the linear deterministic field equation. For an initial state diagonal in in-mode occupation numbers , with no anomalous correlations, the more general expectation is .
For continuous spectra, sums become integrals and normalized wave packets avoid meaningless squares of delta functions. A finite total count requires the appropriate convergence of the double sum or integral. The bosonic mode mixing implementability condition is that be Hilbert-Schmidt; otherwise the two Fock representations need not be unitarily equivalent, even though the local field algebra and finite-mode particle calculations still make sense. This distinction between deterministic field evolution and a chosen representation is essential to quantum field theory in curved spacetime.
The second law of black-hole mechanics states that the total area of a classical future event horizon cannot decrease toward the future, under the appropriate causal and energy assumptions. Use the null convergence condition ; in general relativity the Einstein field equations imply it from the null energy condition. Assume, as allowed here, that the horizon's null generators remain on the horizon and are complete to the future. The horizon is an achronal boundary, and its smooth generators are hypersurface-orthogonal, so their null twist is zero. The Null Raychaudhuri equation therefore gives
If some smooth horizon point had , then while the optical description remains regular, stays negative and
Thus
forcing focusing no later than .
The assumed geometrical result is that this focusing produces a conjugate point to a spacelike surface, namely a focal point relative to a small spacelike horizon cross-section through the original point. A null geodesic beyond such a focal point ceases to generate an achronal boundary: a timelike variation connects the cross-section to points just beyond it. Since the cross-section and the generator lie on the achronal horizon, this is impossible. Future completeness ensures that a singular endpoint cannot terminate the generator before the finite focusing parameter. This future-complete horizon focusing proof of the area theorem rules out .
Therefore on smooth horizon pieces, and the transverse-area identity gives
Integrating over generators proves area nondecrease between later cross-sections. At crease sets, new generators may enter the horizon from the past, adding area; horizon generators do not leave it toward the future under the stated assumptions. Hence the statement also applies to total horizon area through black-hole mergers. Hawking's area theorem is classical: quantum stress-energy can violate the null energy condition, so it does not forbid a shrinking evaporating black hole.
Transport two connecting vectors between neighbouring rays so that they commute with , and project them onto the screen. Their infinitesimal transverse lengths and angles evolve according to the symmetric part of the optical tensor. The trace part gives uniform fractional dilation, while the trace-free null shear stretches one transverse direction and contracts the other, changing a circular beam to an ellipse without changing its area to first order. With zero null twist, there is no antisymmetric rotation of the beam.
If is the metric on an infinitesimal transverse element, then . Its area therefore obeys
Thus positive null expansion means a beam's cross-sectional area increases, and negative expansion means it decreases; null shear records the directional distortion rather than this overall area change.
The Frobenius theorem says that hypersurface orthogonality of the nonzero covector is equivalent to , or locally for some nonzero . This immediately makes the screen projection of zero, since its antisymmetric part is a wedge product with , which is proportional to . Thus hypersurface orthogonality gives zero null twist.
For the converse, put . Nullness gives , and the affine geodesic equation gives . Resolve both tensor slots in the basis consisting of and the screen. These two identities exclude covector factors of . Consequently
for some covector . If , wedging this identity with makes . Applying Frobenius theorem completes the proof:
This is the null twist vanishes exactly for hypersurface-orthogonal geodesics criterion; the geodesic assumption ensures that the screen criterion implies the full Frobenius condition. The resulting hypersurfaces are null, and the congruence follows their null generators.
A null geodesic congruence is a smooth family of null geodesics filling a region, with one curve through each point before caustics form. Choose an affine parameter and tangent , so and . Choose a null partner with , transported parallel to along each generator. The screen-space projector
projects onto the positive-definite two-dimensional plane transverse to . Define the optical tensor and its decomposition by
where
These are respectively the null expansion, null shear and null twist, the latter also called rotation. In the Null Raychaudhuri equation, and use the screen metric. The trace convention for is important: it is not half the trace. For an affine null tangent it also equals .
For , the ring is a naked singularity and there is no event horizon shielding the extension's closed timelike curves. The weak cosmic censorship conjecture predicts that such superextreme Kerr geometries are not formed by generic collapse of regular isolated initial data satisfying the appropriate energy conditions. This is a conjectural physical restriction, not a proof from the exact metric alone.
For , the closed timelike curves lie deep inside the ideal analytic extension, beyond the inner Cauchy horizon, so weak cosmic censorship does not itself exclude them. However, that inner horizon is unstable to perturbations, with mass inflation expected in realistic collapse. The strong cosmic censorship conjecture is the relevant obstruction to a regular continuation into the ideal chronology-violating region. Thus the exact Kerr extension exhibits such curves mathematically, but neither regular collapse nor the uniqueness theorem establishes that they occur in Nature.
During gravitational collapse, nonspherical time-dependent multipoles can be lost in gravitational radiation or absorbed by the forming black hole. Matter remaining outside must ultimately escape or fall in if the final object is to be an isolated vacuum black hole. Assume that the classical exterior settles to a regular stationary asymptotically flat vacuum geometry, with a connected horizon and the regularity conditions of the black-hole uniqueness theorem. This settling assumption is physical input, rather than a consequence of charge conservation alone.
For a rotating remnant, the black-hole rigidity theorem supplies axial symmetry; the uniqueness theorem then identifies the exterior as Kerr spacetime. The nonrotating equilibrium case is Schwarzschild spacetime. Gravitational radiation carries energy and angular momentum but no net electric charge. In the intended neutral collapse, with no net charge carried away by expelled matter, charge conservation therefore leaves zero black-hole charge. Initial total neutrality alone would not prove this if oppositely charged matter were expelled; the two-parameter conclusion assumes the uncharged vacuum remnant just described. This leaves
as its two intrinsic continuous parameters. The final are what remain after escaping matter and radiation have carried off their shares; they need not equal the star's initial values. A spatial rotation may align the spin axis, and a translation or boost chooses the position and rest frame, so these do not add intrinsic parameters. All higher equilibrium multipoles are fixed by ; for example Kerr's mass quadrupole is . A regular Kerr black hole obeys in geometrized units. This is the content of the black-hole no-hair theorem in vacuum general relativity, with its stated hypotheses, rather than a statement about arbitrary matter theories or an unproved guarantee of dynamical settling. Hawking evaporation is ignored in this classical late-time equilibrium description.
An asymptotically flat spacetime is a stationary spacetime if it admits a complete stationary Killing vector field , with , timelike near infinity and normalized there to a unit time translation. It need not remain timelike in an ergoregion of a stationary spacetime. It is axisymmetric if it admits an axial Killing vector field , whose flow is a rotational action: its spacelike orbits away from the axis are closed with period , and it vanishes on the regular rotation axis. For a stationary axisymmetric spacetime, the generators can be chosen to commute, . These are geometric symmetries, not merely time-independent or angle-independent coordinate labels.
There is only one zero of , at , and the Kruskal–Szekeres coordinates give four quadrants. Both exterior quadrants have , while the future and past interior quadrants have . The tortoise coordinate is finite at : for , , and for it is . Throughout each interior , so constant- hypersurfaces are spacelike. The assumed curvature singularity at therefore forms a spacelike future boundary in the black-hole region and a spacelike past boundary in the white-hole region. At infinity, and , giving two standard asymptotically flat ends.
The resulting Penrose diagram is the same four-region causal diagram as the maximal Schwarzschild spacetime:
Figure 1.
Maximal extension of the charged single-horizon geometry, with two exteriors, a black hole, a white hole and spacelike singularities
. Details.
Each exterior has its own past null infinity, future null infinity, spatial infinity and timelike infinities. The future and past event horizons intersect on the bifurcation surface. The diagram describes the eternal analytic solution; a spacetime formed by collapse need not contain its white-hole region or second exterior.
Unlike a nonextreme Reissner-Nordstrom black hole, this electrically charged solution has one horizon and spacelike singularities, with no inner Cauchy horizon. A nonextreme Reissner-Nordstrom solution has two distinct horizons, including an inner Cauchy horizon, and a timelike singularity; its ideal maximal extension contains an infinite sequence of exterior and interior blocks. Charge by itself does not determine this causal structure: the metric and field equations of the gravitational theory matter.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact