 Solution

virial pressure-radius curve with uniform-sphere binding energy. Put $c_s^2=k_{B}T/\mu$. Isothermality makes $\int (p/\rho )dM=c_s^2{M}_0$, so the virial theorem givesThe curve crosses zero at $r_z=B/A=G{M}_0/(5c_s^2)$, rises to its maximum atthen decreases toward zero at large radius. Since $p_0^{\prime }=(4B-3A{r}_0)/r_0^5$, a cloud displaced outward at fixed external pressure has a restoring pressure deficit only on the descending branch. Thus the homologous, isothermal radial mode is stable for $r_0>r_c$, unstable for $r_z<r_0<r_c$, and marginal at $r_c$. The negative-pressure branch is not a physical equilibrium with a positive confining pressure. This conclusion uses the stipulated gravitational-energy approximation, not the exact isothermal density profile.

critical mass from a virial pressure turning point. At the turning point, $B=3A{r}_c/4$; henceUsing the cloud's mean density $\bar{\rho }=3M_0/(4\pi r_0^3)$, the condition $r_0>4G{M}_0/(15c_s^2)$ becomesUsing the boundary density instead changes the numerical coefficient, not this scaling. The coefficient should not be identified with the exact Bonnor-Ebert sphere threshold because the assumed potential energy is different.

mass and luminosity weighting of a stellar initial mass function. Impose finite birth-mass cutoffs $m_l,m_u$. The stellar birth mass and main-sequence luminosity scale asFor a broad mass interval, the low-mass end controls the first integral and the high-mass end the second. Per logarithmic mass interval the weights are respectively $m^2\xi \propto m^{-0.35}$ and $mL\xi \propto m^{2.65}$. Finite lifetimes remove massive stars from an aging population, so the luminosity conclusion applies while those stars remain on the main sequence.

exponential closed-box gas consumption. The gross formation rate is $\Psi =ϵM_g$, but the permanent locking rate is $\alpha \Psi$. The instantaneous recycling approximation and mass conservation give ${\dot{M}}_g=-\alpha ϵM_g$, ${\dot{M}}_{\ast }=\alpha ϵM_g$. ThereforeHere $M_{\ast }$ means surviving locked stellar mass in the galactic gas fraction, not the cumulative gross mass that has passed through star formation.

locked-mass and returned-mass yield conventions. Pre-existing metals are locked at rate $\alpha Z\Psi$; the stipulated newly produced metal source is $b(1-\alpha )\Psi$. ThusFor $\alpha >0$ and initially pristine gas,The effective yield $y$ is per unit permanently locked mass; it is not the source parameter $b$. For $\alpha =0$, $M_g=M_0$ and the direct time equation gives $Z=bϵt$. For $\alpha =1$, the explicitly stipulated metal source vanishes, so this particular enrichment model gives $Z=0$. Constant yield is a trace-enrichment approximation; the formal logarithmic divergence as gas is exhausted must not be interpreted as a physical metal fraction exceeding one.

backward extrapolation of exponential closed-box star formation. Denote the present age of the universe by $t_{\mathrm{now}}$. With the last paragraph's $\alpha =1$,TODO: a present age of the universe or cosmology is needed for a unique numerical estimate. For the explicitly illustrative choice $t_{\mathrm{now}}=13.8\mathrm{Gyr}$, this is about $365M_{\odot }\mathrm{y}{\mathrm{r}}^{-1}$, requiring $7.3\times 10^{11}{M}_{\odot }$ of gas at that epoch in the same model. This is an extreme history for a present Milky-Way-like system, although intense high-redshift star formation by itself is not forbidden.

The extrapolation forces a fixed gas reservoir to decline exponentially over many gas-depletion times. Gas accretion, outflows, evolving gas density and star-formation efficiency, delayed recycling, and galaxy assembly break that assumption. The empirical disk-averaged relation is not a universal constant-efficiency law for all gas: the original measurements combined Balmer series H-alpha, atomic gas, carbon monoxide and infrared data, with tracer calibration and dust corrections entering the inference.^[ref] Cosmological calculations explicitly support continuing cold-gas supply to rapidly forming high-redshift galaxies, providing a physical alternative to this closed-box backward extrapolation.^[ref]