Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-mathematics-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2003/iii/paper-15/1/solution

We work over an algebraically closed field , so the assertion concerns a geometric projective line. Let and let be the vector space of homogeneous cubic forms on . It has dimension , so the parameter space of cubic equations up to nonzero scalar is . The Grassmannian parametrizes lines in . Its standard graph charts are four-dimensional affine spaces, so its dimension is four. The Plücker embedding realizes it as a closed quadric in , proving projectivity. The general linear group acts transitively on two-planes and is an irreducible open subset of the affine space of matrices; its orbit map proves that is irreducible.
Consider the incidence variety
Restriction of a cubic to a fixed line is surjective onto the four-dimensional space of binary cubic forms: after choosing coordinates with that line given by , extend any binary cubic using alone. Thus its kernel has dimension sixteen. On each Grassmannian chart these restriction maps depend algebraically on the line parameters and have constant rank four. Their kernels form a rank-sixteen vector bundle, and is its projective bundle, with fibre . In particular, is irreducible of dimension . It is closed in the product, since restriction vanishes precisely when four polynomial coefficients vanish.
The projection is a projective morphism, hence its image is closed. It remains to prove that this image has dimension nineteen. Equal dimensions alone would not suffice: we must control a fibre locally.
Take
In the open Grassmannian chart around , every line is uniquely a graph
Restriction of to that line is
The four monomials are linearly independent over every field. Hence the only line in this chart lying on has . The fibre therefore has local dimension zero at . We do not need to define a smooth surface, nor do we claim its entire fibre is finite.
The fiber dimension theorem, in its local dimension inequality, gives
Thus the closed image has dimension at least nineteen. A proper closed subset of the irreducible has smaller dimension, so . Every cubic equation consequently has a line in its zero set. In particular, every nonsingular cubic surface contains a line. The proof in fact establishes existence for arbitrary cubic surfaces over an algebraically closed field; it does not assert a rational line over an arbitrary nonclosed ground field.

New to topics? Read the docs here!