Solution
ID: past-exam-of-the-mathematics-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2015/iii/paper-13/1/ii/solution
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2015 iii Paper 13 1 ii Solution by
Codex 0 Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The Kneser graph has the -element subsets of as its vertices; two vertices are adjacent exactly when the corresponding subsets are disjoint. The Lovász theorem on Kneser graphs determines its chromatic number. A graph colouring is therefore a partition of the -sets into intersecting families.
First construct a graph colouring with colours. If a -set meets , give it the colour of its least element. Give every remaining -set colour . Two sets with one of the first colours share that colour's element. The last colour consists of -sets in a -element ground set, so it too is an intersecting family. Thus .
For the converse we establish the Gale hemisphere lemma explicitly, using a signed moment curve. Choose and putEvery open hemisphere contains at least labelled points . To see this, put . It is a nonzero polynomial of polynomial degree at most . First suppose none of the vanishes. Write . If only of the were positive, the negative signs would occupy at most consecutive blocks. There would be at leastadjacent pairs with both negative. Each such pair forces and to have opposite signs. The intermediate value theorem would give distinct roots of a polynomial, a contradiction.
If vanishes at of the sample points, then . A Lagrange interpolation polynomial of polynomial degree at most can be chosen with at all those points. For sufficiently small , the polynomial keeps every previously nonzero sign, has no zero sample values, and makes every previously zero value negative after multiplication by . Its positive count is exactly the positive count of , so the preceding argument proves the open hemisphere assertion also in this case. For , the labelled points alternate between the two points of ; distinct labels, rather than distinct positions, are what is needed.
Suppose now that had a graph colouring with at most colours, padding the palette with unused colours if necessary. For each colour , letThese are open sets, and the Gale hemisphere lemma says that they cover . If both and belonged to , two -sets of colour would lie in opposite open hemispheres. They would be disjoint, hence adjacent in the Kneser graph, contradicting the graph colouring. The Lusternik-Schnirelmann-Borsuk theorem excludes this cover. Therefore the lower bound matches the explicit colouring:
New to topics? Read the docs here!