Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-mathematics-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2017/iii/paper-341/3/ii/solution

The printed formula is not a consistent spatial discretization of the stated PDE. The original PDF genuinely has , rather than . Writing , the Taylor expansion gives
so it approximates a diffusion coefficient tending to zero. Moreover, and cover , whereas the given Dirichlet boundary conditions belong to . No value at the interior location was prescribed. These are actual source defects, not repairs justified by the TeX conversion.
A conditional analysis of the literal ordinary differential equation system is still possible. If it is closed by imposing on the displayed grid, the negative Dirichlet discrete Laplacian has positive frequencies squared
and each normal mode obeys . For a fixed mesh, every solution is bounded for all time exactly when
Equality produces a linearly growing normal mode for nonzero modal initial velocity; above the threshold there is an exponentially growing normal mode. Since , any gives bounded continuous solutions but unbounded literal discrete solutions on sufficiently fine meshes. For example, , gives , and a growing first sine normal mode. At , every fixed mesh is bounded for all time, but unit first-mode initial velocity has maximal displacement , which diverges on mesh refinement. For uniform-in-mesh, all-time displacement bounds for arbitrary bounded displacement/velocity data in the mesh-weighted L2 norm, the literal closed system therefore requires .
This differs from finite-time stability of a numerical method, governed here by displacement stability of a symmetric semidiscrete wave equation. For the conditional closure above, diagonalization of a matrix gives, with ,
Oscillatory modes use , including its value at ; growing modes use . Thus the displacement map is mesh-uniformly bounded on each fixed finite time interval for every fixed real . This is a legitimate finite-time displacement stability estimate, but neither consistency of a numerical method nor the all-time conclusion of part (i). It does not assert a velocity bound in the unweighted displacement norm.
If the intended method instead uses and the full interval, take interior indices , , with zeros at . Its first positive discrete eigenvalue is
The corrected, fixed-mesh all-time condition is , with the same strictness at equality. For every fixed , this holds on all sufficiently fine meshes. This corrected interpretation is stated separately rather than silently replacing the PDF.

New to topics? Read the docs here!