 Solution

Use a Lagrange multiplier to maximize $V=\pi r^{2}h$ subject to $2\pi r(r+h)=A$, with $r,h>0$. The equations $\nabla V=\lambda \nabla A$ areThe second equation gives $\lambda =r/2$. Substituting into the first gives $2rh=r(2r+h)$, hence $h=2r$. The constraint then gives $A=6\pi r^2$, soThis is the same aspect ratio as the minimum-area closed cylinder at fixed volume. To confirm maximality directly, eliminate $h$: $V(r)=Ar/2-\pi r^3$ on $0<r<\sqrt{A/(2\pi )}$. Its only stationary point is the value above, its second derivative there is negative, and the volume tends to zero at either end of the interval.