Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-physics-1-paper-of-the-university-of-oxford/2015-resit/7/solution

Plot position horizontally and vertically, with equal length scales, so vacuum light rays have slopes . A possible cause of the spacetime event must lie on or inside its past light cone, with . Equivalently, causality requires .
From to , and . Using , the available light-travel distance is only . In the metric signature, the Minkowski interval is
There is spacelike separation, so a signal would need speed :
From to , and . Now , giving
This is timelike separation, with a possible signal velocity . Therefore
Figure 1.
The past light cone of event A contains C but excludes B
. Original spacetime diagram using in metres and . The dashed B-to-A segment would require a superluminal signal; the C-to-A segment has a physically allowed subluminal slope. Details.

New to topics? Read the docs here!