Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-physics-course-of-the-year-1-of-the-natural-sciences-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2017/section-e/14/solution

In electrostatics, Gauss's law is
The surface normal points outward. Spherical symmetry makes the field radial and constant in magnitude on a concentric Gaussian surface.
For a uniformly charged sphere, enclosed charge is inside and outside. Thus the radial field is
Set potential zero at infinity. Outside, . Inside, integrate from the known boundary value, obtaining
The field rises linearly from zero to its maximum at , then falls as . The potential falls quadratically from to its surface value and then as . Both are continuous at the surface; there is no separate sheet of surface charge.
Figure 1.
Radial field and potential of a uniformly charged solid sphere
. Details.
For the electric field of a hydrogen ground-state electron cloud, its enclosed charge is
Writing and using gives
The total electron-cloud charge tends to , as required. Dividing by yields
The expression is negative and therefore points inward. Its apparently singular terms cancel at small radius, leaving .
A distant external charge polarizes the neutral atom. Its electric field displaces the positive and negative charge distributions relative to one another, giving an induced dipole with static electric polarizability . The field is stronger on the nearer side, so the opposite-charge attraction exceeds the like-charge repulsion. This is charge-induced dipole attraction, not a net monopole charge on the atom.
Quantitatively, for external charge at separation , the polarization energy is , hence
Here negative means decreasing separation. Reversing the external charge reverses the induced dipole but leaves this leading long-range force attractive and of the same magnitude. The factor one half accounts for the energy cost of inducing the dipole.
The supplied charge density describes the unperturbed atom. Adding its electron field to the nucleus field leaves , an exponentially small residual because the cloud has an infinite tail. A completely frozen density would give only that tiny sign-dependent force. Allowing polarization is essential to obtain the dominant attractive power-law force for either sign of external charge when .

New to topics? Read the docs here!