 Solution

The intended hypothesis must be a proper monic factor, with $1\le r\le p-1$. Without that restriction the printed deduction is false: every polynomial has the displayed trivial factorization with $r=p$, even when it has no root in $F$.

By part 1, the roots in a splitting field are distinct and have the form $\alpha +j$. The degree-$r$ monic factor is the product of $r$ corresponding linear factors. Comparing the coefficient of $X^{r-1}$ using Vieta's formulas givesBoth $a_1$ and the sum of prime-field elements lie in $F$. Since $1\le r<p$, the scalar $r$ is nonzero and invertible in $F$. Therefore $\alpha =(-a_1-{\sum }_{j\in J}j)/r\in F$, and part 1 proves the polynomial splits into distinct linear factors over $F$. In particular an Artin–Schreier polynomial of prime degree is either irreducible or splits completely.