The source'sratio is reversed for this intended explanation. Depleting helium lowers He/H and raises H/He. For a concrete example, keeping ten hydrogen units while reducing one helium unit to one half changes H/He from ten to twenty, not to a lower value. Thus the literal statement that Saturn has lower H/He cannot simultaneously be used asevidence for the stated upper-envelope helium-depletion mechanism. If the intended comparison is lower He/H, the observations and extra heat are mutually consistent with heliumrain. Composition measurements and interior modeling are still needed; excess heat alone does not uniquely prove that process.[ref]