Label the edges so that barycentric coordinates on satisfy
Suppose for contradiction that . The distance from a point to a closed set gives continuous nonnegative functions . Their sum never vanishes, while at every point at least one of them vanishes because . Hence
is a continuous map from to its boundary in barycentric-coordinate space. Moreover, , , and . On each edge, the straight-line homotopy between and the identity remains in that edge, so has winding number one. On the other hand, a map from the whole triangle to its boundary makes its boundary restriction null-homotopic, and hence gives winding number zero. This contradiction proves the three-set covering lemma:
If a retraction fixed every boundary point, choose a homeomorphism from to taking its three edges to three consecutive closed arcs of with empty triple intersection. The inverse images under of those arcs would be closed, would cover , and would contain the corresponding boundary arcs. Transporting them to would contradict the result just proved. Therefore
For the final statement, use compactness of the three closed arcs inside the corresponding open sets. A finite open cover of a compact metric space admits a closed shrinking, and the shrinking can be chosen to preserve specified compact subsets already lying in the respective open sets. Thus there are closed sets
which cover and contain , respectively. The disc version of the three-set covering lemma, obtained from the triangle by a homeomorphism taking its edges to the three arcs, gives a point in . Since these sets lie in the original open sets,
The Hubble parameter is the fractional expansion rate
Here is the homogeneous energy density, records the sign of the spatial curvature of an FLRW universe, and is the fixed curvature length scale used with the dimensionless scale factor .
Energy-momentum conservation in a homogeneous expanding universe gives the continuity equation
Differentiate the Friedmann equation
Using and the continuity equation gives
Eliminating the curvature term with the Friedmann equation yields
Since , this is the Raychaudhuri equation
Under the strong energy condition , one has . Thus is concave, and for it lies below its tangent at the present time:
The right side vanishes at . A positive scale factor therefore cannot extend regularly to that time; it must reach the Big Bang singularity at some . Equivalently,
Let each mass be and each spring constant be , with the denoting longitudinal displacements from equilibrium. The Lagrangian is
The inverse coordinate transformation is
Substitution gives
Thus the Euler-Lagrange equations separate into a symmetric pair,
and an antisymmetric pair,
The symmetric normal modes are:
  • , corresponding to and the translational frequency
  • , corresponding to and
For antisymmetric modes, the squared dimensionless frequencies are the eigenvalues of
namely . They give
and
In the original coordinates their mode shapes are respectively
and

There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.