Canonical transformation of mode operators 2026-10-07
A linear change of creation operators and annihilation operators is canonical when it preserves their defining brackets. For finitely many bosonic modes, the canonical commutation relations require and . For fermions, the canonical anticommutation relations instead require and . A Bogoliubov transformation uses such mixing to diagonalize a quadratic Hamiltonian or relate different vacuum descriptions. Infinite-mode unitary implementation has further conditions, as in bosonic mode mixing implementability.
Multimode squeezed vacuum Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-10-20
For an invertible finite-mode Bogoliubov transformation , the symmetric squeezing matrix is . The canonical commutation relations make its singular values strictly less than one. The normalized state has . Infinitely many modes additionally require bosonic mode mixing implementability.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2006 iii Paper 63 4 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Use a free real scalar field obeying a linear Klein-Gordon equation, for example . This linearity is the assumption that permits mode evolution by a Bogoliubov transformation. Work with a complete set of normalized modes, or normalizable wave packets when the spectrum is continuous. The stationary asymptotic regions supply time translations relative to which positive-frequency solutions and their complex conjugates can be distinguished.
For solutions define the conserved Klein-Gordon inner productHere is a Cauchy surface with future-directed normal. Its conservation follows by applying the wave equation to the divergence of its current, provided boundary flux is included or vanishes. Let be a positive-frequency basis in the past and one in the future, each propagated as a solution through the intermediate geometry. Normalize them by , and , with the corresponding identities for the future basis. The two field expansions areThe canonical commutation relations give and . The in-vacuum satisfies , while the out-vacuum satisfies . They are generally different vacua.
Fix the coefficient convention by expanding future modes in past modes:The minus sign is due to the negative norm of the conjugate modes. Taking the Klein-Gordon inner product with the field, which is antilinear in its first entry, givesBoth frequency sectors are needed: if , a future annihilation operator contains a past creation operator. This is the mechanism of particle number from Bogoliubov coefficients, not a classical nonzero mean field.
Computing and explicitly gives the canonical identities for a bosonic Bogoliubov transformation:Completeness also gives the inverse . Thus the evolved past vacuum, viewed in the future Fock space, obeysFor a finite-mode treatment with invertible , solve this condition by a multimode squeezed vacuum:The canonical identities make symmetric. Commuting through the exponential gives , which directly verifies the vacuum condition. Its normalization is . A general initial state is obtained by applying its initial creation-operator polynomial and expressing those operators in the future basis. In infinitely many modes, a common unitary Fock representation requires the creation-mixing coefficients to be Hilbert-Schmidt; finite wave-packet counts avoid treating delta-normalized modes as individual normalizable states. These are the bosonic mode mixing implementability conditions, rather than an assumption of arbitrary finite total creation over an infinite time interval.
For the requested number operator of one future mode, set . Expectations below are in the evolved past vacuum , equivalently in using the Heisenberg-mode operators above. Acting on the past vacuum gives , whose squared norm isThe mean particle number vanishes exactly when that mode has no negative-frequency mixing.
The second moment needs the anomalous contractionThe canonical commutation relations give . Moreover,Its vacuum and two-particle pieces are orthogonal. Applying the commutation relations twice showsThe two pairings each contribute to the squared norm. Hence the full answer isThus . These are the out-mode number fluctuations in the in-vacuum. Omitting would assume a property not given in the general question. A thermal single mode has , giving . A single-mode squeezed vacuum state instead has , giving .
If the counted observable is the total number over a finite set of future modes, its moments follow by retaining cross-mode correlations as well. Define and . The same vacuum pairings give . Thus and , with and . Independent thermal counts cannot be assumed for a general correlated squeezed state.
For Hawking radiation, choose the incoming vacuum at past null infinity of a collapse spacetime and propagate late outgoing modes backwards. Near a nonextremal forming event horizon, the logarithmic tortoise-coordinate divergence leads to the Hawking exponential ray mapwhere is late retarded time, is an early regular affine null coordinate and is the final surface gravity. A late positive-frequency mode therefore becomes proportional to on rays escaping just before horizon formation. This is not positive-frequency with respect to : it has both frequency signs and hence nonzero .
The thermal factor can be seen directly. With , and a regulator , the relevant Fourier integrals areAs , the arguments of the two complex factors approach . Their squared-modulus ratio for the suppressed and enhanced frequency branches is . Thus the thermal ratio of Hawking Bogoliubov coefficients, combined with the canonical normalization, yields the bosonic occupationin units . Scattering through the exterior potential multiplies the asymptotic occupation by the appropriate greybody factor.
A complete future mode description includes modes crossing the horizon as well as modes reaching future null infinity. The global incoming vacuum develops correlations between these sectors; restricting to the exterior gives approximately thermal outgoing occupation rather than a claim that the complete pure state became a thermal mixed state. This is the particle-production picture of a collapsing black hole, not an incoming thermal bath on an eternal geometry. Including backreaction turns the emitted positive energy into black-hole mass loss. The renormalized quantum stress tensor is not subject to the pointwise classical positivity used in the black-hole area theorem, so this does not contradict its classical proof.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 iii Paper 56 4 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Use a real free Klein-Gordon field on a prescribed four-dimensional globally hyperbolic spacetime, with signature and . A mass and curvature coupling give the quadratic actionand the field equation . Minimal coupling is ; for a massless scalar in four dimensions, conformal coupling is . Global hyperbolicity supplies a Cauchy hypersurface and a well-posed initial-value problem: suitable data on determine a unique solution. One assumes appropriate support or decay conditions so no unaccounted flux crosses spatial infinity. The geometry is classical here; quantum backreaction is a further problem.
The real solution space has the conserved symplectic form on scalar-field solutionsIts complexification defines the Klein-Gordon inner productThe divergence of its current is by the field equation, proving independence of the chosen Cauchy hypersurface. This Hermitian form is not positive definite on the whole complex solution space: conjugating a solution reverses its norm.
Choose a complete positive-norm mode space and basis satisfyingHere completeness means that every real solution expands in these modes and their conjugates. Equivalently, one chooses a compatible complex structure on the Klein-Gordon solution space; this is extra data, not fixed by the field equation. Quantization replaces the mode coefficients by annihilation operators and creation operators:In a foliation with induced metric determinant , the canonical momentum is . The normalized complete mode expansion implements the equal-time canonical commutation relations and vanishing field-field and momentum-momentum commutators on . Propagation by the field equation gives microcausality: field observables commute at spacelike separation. Thus there is a local quantum field theory before one has selected a particle interpretation.
The chosen positive-mode space completes to a one-particle Hilbert space . Its bosonic Fock space is . The Fock vacuum obeys ; acting with produces multiparticle states, and counts particles in mode . The vacuum two-point function is . The Hadamard condition restricts physically admissible states by prescribing their local short-distance singularity; it permits renormalization of the stress-energy tensor but does not select one unique vacuum.
The particle ambiguity is that there is generally no distinguished choice of positive-mode space. A second complete normalized basis can beThe Bogoliubov transformation preserves the mode normalization precisely whenIts operators obey . Consequently a state with no -particles generally has -particles if . A unitary change of basis within the same positive-mode space has and merely relabels modes; a change mixing the positive and negative subspaces changes the vacuum and particle notion. Arbitrary coordinates called “time” do not resolve this choice. This is the vacuum ambiguity in a nonstationary spacetime, while the field equation and local commutator remain unchanged.
In the standard stationary setting, a complete future-directed timelike Killing vector field generates a time-translation symmetry. With a stable positive energy operator and suitable boundary conditions, choose positive-frequency solutions byThe positive stationary Hamiltonian selects a particle splitting: positive spectral modes define annihilation operators, and the normal-ordered Hamiltonian is . Its ground state is the vacuum state in a stationary spacetime. The Killing symmetry transports this splitting unchanged, so no positive-negative mixing is induced by stationary evolution. Degeneracies allow unitary basis changes without changing the vacuum. Stationarity fixes the ground-state particle interpretation relative to this time flow; it does not forbid excited or thermal states.
The qualification is that asymptotic stationarity alone, in the sense used for a Kerr exterior, is insufficient for a global positive-energy construction: becomes spacelike in an ergoregion of a stationary spacetime. The usual unambiguous construction applies to a strictly stationary spacetime with the stated stability and spectral assumptions, or to appropriate stationary asymptotic regions for scattering. Zero modes or instability need separate treatment. Likewise different observer time flows on different regions need not define the same particles.
For particle creation by a nonstationary spacetime, choose normalized positive-frequency modes in the stationary early region and in the stationary late region. Propagate both sets by the Klein-Gordon equation through the intermediate time-dependent geometry. Compute their overlaps on any common Cauchy hypersurface:The initial in-vacuum has . Since , contracting the in operators yields the particle number from Bogoliubov coefficients:Thus the procedure is to fix asymptotic mode choices, solve the classical wave equation, project using the conserved inner product, and take squared negative-frequency overlaps. Particle energy comes from the time-dependent background, so particle creation does not contradict the linear deterministic field equation. For an initial state diagonal in in-mode occupation numbers , with no anomalous correlations, the more general expectation is .
For continuous spectra, sums become integrals and normalized wave packets avoid meaningless squares of delta functions. A finite total count requires the appropriate convergence of the double sum or integral. The bosonic mode mixing implementability condition is that be Hilbert-Schmidt; otherwise the two Fock representations need not be unitarily equivalent, even though the local field algebra and finite-mode particle calculations still make sense. This distinction between deterministic field evolution and a chosen representation is essential to quantum field theory in curved spacetime.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 51 4 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Canonical mode mixing and its inverse. Treat annihilation operators as column vectors and keep complex conjugation, transpose and Hermitian adjoint distinct. Computing the canonical commutation relations for givesConsequently the required conditions areFor complete invertible mode mixing, putThe canonical identities for a bosonic Bogoliubov transformation are , giving . Its upper blocks yieldEquivalently, the column identities are and . In finite dimension invertibility follows from the canonical matrix identity. In infinitely many modes, the row identities alone need not give a complete inverse: preserves them but discards one mode. Here completeness of the two field-mode expansions supplies the needed invertible transformation.
Obtaining coefficients from the modes. Use the Klein-Gordon inner product, antilinear in its first argument,The normalized positive-frequency solutions satisfy , and . Current conservation makes this product independent of the Cauchy hypersurface when boundary flux vanishes. Taking the product of the field with a mode gives and henceWith this operator convention, the corresponding mode expansion isThe minus sign comes from the negative norm of conjugate modes. Using a different convention for mode coefficients can move this sign and the complex conjugates; the operator formula fixes them unambiguously here.
Particle count. In the in-vacuum, only the contraction survives. ThereforeThis is particle number from Bogoliubov coefficients: the old vacuum contains that expected number of particles in the new mode . Nonzero negative-frequency mixing is the source of particle production. For continuum modes one uses normalized wave packets and replaces the sum by the corresponding integral.
The squeezed-state relation. First use finitely many modes, or an implementable infinite-mode limit. SeekThe canonical commutation relations giveAll further nested commutators vanish since contains only creation operators. ThusThe old annihilation conditions hold exactly whenThe inverse transformation's canonical identity shows , so the required symmetry is automatic. Also givesHence the singular values of are less than one. The Autonne-Takagi factorization changes to independent canonical oscillators. For each factor, the squared norm of is the even-occupation seriesMultiplying these norms gives the finite-mode normalizationThe phase of is arbitrary. The resulting multimode squeezed vacuum is annihilated by all old annihilation operators, so uniqueness of the normalized Fock vacuum identifies it with .
The PDF's squeezed-vacuum claim needs qualification for infinitely many modes. Bosonic mode mixing implementability requires to be a Hilbert-Schmidt operator, , for a common ordinary bosonic Fock space. For a counterexample, take and on countably many modes with fixed . The algebraic canonical conditions hold, but and the finite- normalization is . Every mode has a fixed positive probability of nonzero occupation in the required product state; the probability that all but finitely many modes are empty is zero. Ordinary Fock space vectors instead have total occupation finite with probability one, even if their expected occupation is infinite. Thus there is no nonzero common-Fock-space vector of the prescribed form. The squeezed expression is a normalizable vacuum relation with a finite-mode regulator or the implementability condition, not solely from the commutator identities.
Black-hole radiation. In a collapse spacetime, choose early positive-frequency solutions with respect to affine incoming time on past null infinity, and late outgoing modes proportional to on future null infinity. The early state is their in-vacuum. The Hawking exponential ray map hasfor late outgoing rays, with . Tracing a late mode backwards therefore gives a profile proportional toIt is not a pure positive-frequency incoming wave, so the Bogoliubov transformation has nonzero .
To see the thermal factor, put and . The positive- and negative-frequency Fourier pieces have, apart from common normalization and phases, the regulated integralsAs , the positive-frequency piece has squared-modulus factor and the negative-frequency piece has . Consequently the thermal ratio of Hawking Bogoliubov coefficients isFor a normalized narrow-frequency outgoing wave packet, combine this ratio with . The occupation is the Bose-Einstein distributionThe Hawking temperature is thus the same one found by Euclidean regularity. For Schwarzschild, gives in natural units. Propagation through the exterior potential multiplies the asymptotic occupation by the greybody factor .
The outgoing radiation has partner-mode correlations across the horizon: the total state can be pure while the reduced outgoing state is thermal. A complete mode basis must include modes entering the horizon as well as those reaching infinity. The particle statement is made for normalized packets and finite observation intervals; idealized infinite-duration emission need not define the two vacua in one global Fock space. This explains both the squeezed-state structure and the physically measurable Hawking radiation.