Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2003 iii Paper 50 5 b Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
The first massless level of a closed string contains a spin-two field, an antisymmetric two-form and a scalar: the graviton, Kalb–Ramond field and dilaton. The polarization redundancies found in Question 2 become, in position space, the linearized transformations and . Thus the massless spin-two field already carries the gauge symmetry of linearized general relativity.
To describe slowly varying backgrounds, promote these polarizations to fields of the embedding coordinates. The Euclidean string nonlinear sigma model isHere is the antisymmetric coordinate density. Quantum consistency requires worldsheet Weyl anomaly cancellation, not merely the classical background equations. At first order in the bosonic sigma-model Weyl anomaly coefficients givewhere is the Kalb-Ramond field strength. The scalar anomaly condition, combined with the trace of the metric condition in the critical dimension, givesThese are the Euler–Lagrange equations of the leading string-frame massless effective actionFor example, variation of gives the divergence equation above. Varying and integrating its kinetic variation by parts gives . Combining this with the metric variation yields the Ricci equation. Thus the string's quantum conformal consistency reproduces target-space gravity coupled to matter. Equivalently, expanding string scattering amplitudes at small momenta gives the same action: massless exchange poles are reproduced by these fields, while analytic terms from massive exchange become local higher-derivative interactions.
The apparent dilaton-dependent coefficient of is a frame choice. Put and, in dimension , define the Einstein-frame metricTo see the cancellation explicitly, write , . ThenThe Laplacian term is a boundary term. Combining the last term with the original positive dilaton kinetic term produces . The three inverse metrics in give its remaining exponential factor. HenceFor the uncompactified bosonic theory , these coefficients are and . The Ricci term is now the Einstein-Hilbert action; its metric variation gives the Einstein field equations with stress-energy tensor from the scalar and two-form. The leading low-energy theory is general relativity coupled to the massless string fields.
The approximation requires characteristic momenta and small curvature in string units. Massive string modes have masses of order and can be integrated out, generating corrections with extra powers of or . The string genus expansion supplies independent loop corrections controlled by ; at weak coupling tree-level gravity dominates. Dimensional analysis gives .
Compactification supplies lower-dimensional gravity and additional matter: metric and two-form components give gauge fields, internal geometry gives scalar moduli, and light modes of Kaluza-Klein theory must be kept if their masses lie below the chosen cutoff. Open strings add gauge fields, and supersymmetric string theories add spacetime fermions. Their particular matter spectrum depends on the compactification and projection; universal massless spin-two interactions retain the gravitational form. Finally, the bosonic massless-sector action is a formal truncation around a tachyonically unstable vacuum. It does not remove that instability. Tachyon-free superstring backgrounds provide stable applications of this low-energy gravitational interpretation.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2007 iii Paper 54 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For an oriented Euclidean string worldsheet with metric , use the string nonlinear sigma model actionHere is an antisymmetric density with . The factor in the Euclidean Kalb–Ramond field term follows from continuing the real Lorentzian two-form coupling; reversing orientation or the convention for reverses its sign. The conventional positive Euclidean dilaton coupling is being used. With worldsheet boundaries its curvature coupling also needs , where is the boundary geodesic curvature, to have the proper topological normalization for constant .
All three terms are invariant under worldsheet diffeomorphisms. Target-coordinate changes act on by their ordinary scalar and tensor transformation rules, making the target description covariant as well. For the two-form there is also the target gauge symmetry . Its change in the closed-worldsheet action is an integral of an exact two-form and hence zero. With boundaries it is instead ; an endpoint gauge field with cancels it.
Under a local Weyl transformation , the metric term is invariant because the two-dimensional factors and cancel. The term is independent of and is separately invariant. The curvature transforms asOn a closed surface the dilaton variation is consequentlyThus a general nonconstant dilaton term is not separately invariant under Weyl transformations. Its variation is the Weyl variation of a nonconstant dilaton coupling; it vanishes for constant after the boundary completion where necessary.
For , the Gauss-Bonnet theorem gives . In the Euclidean path integral the resulting weight isFor a connected orientable genus- surface with boundaries, , so the weight is . A closed-string handle therefore adds two powers of string coupling. External vertex normalizations add their own coupling factors; they are distinct from this dilaton Euler-characteristic weighting. The constant dilaton controls the string genus expansion, rather than adding a force to the classical embedding equation.
Quantization treats the target fields as position-dependent couplings of a two-dimensional interacting quantum field theory. Expanding around a background embedding gives fluctuation vertices involving target curvature and derivatives of and . Short-distance contractions require local counterterms, so the target fields become renormalized couplings. In particular a curvature vertex contracted once yields a Ricci tensor counterterm proportional to . Each additional sigma-model loop brings another power of and more target derivatives. The expansion is useful when the target variation scale is large compared with ; it is not the separate expansion in powers of .
After gauge fixing, a worldsheet Weyl anomaly would make amplitudes depend on the discarded local conformal factor. Quantum consistency therefore requires the trace anomaly to vanish, including the reparameterization worldsheet ghost field contribution. In a conventional renormalization scheme the resulting bosonic sigma-model Weyl anomaly coefficients start asThe barred quantities include the dilaton stress-energy tensor improvement; ordinary coupling sigma-model beta functions can differ by field redefinitions or target diffeomorphisms. Setting these coefficients to zero gives differential equations for the background fields order by order, including the metric gravitational equation and the antisymmetric-field equation. These conventions for the leading coefficients are described in the background-field lecture notes. Higher orders supply higher-curvature and higher-derivative corrections. This explains how spacetime dynamics follows from quantum gauge consistency of the worldsheet, not from asking only for a classical stationary worldsheet in an arbitrarily chosen background.
The apparently noninvariant dilaton term is essential outside the critical dimension because its stress-energy tensor improvement can cancel the quantum central charge mismatch. A flat constant-dilaton background has matter central charge and worldsheet ghost field central charge . If , changing the constant value of only changes and cannot cure that mismatch.
A concrete solution is the linear dilaton conformal field theory with , , and . Its metric and antisymmetric-field anomaly coefficients vanish, while the scalar condition isOne can also see this cancellation directly from the improved holomorphic stress-energy tensor. With the positive Euclidean curvature convention above,The free-field contraction is . Differentiating it twice at each point gives a fourth-order pole from the improvement. Since the fourth-order stress-tensor pole is , the matter central charge becomes . The worldsheet ghost field contribution then cancels it. This is why a classical Weyl variation need not mean inconsistency: it can cancel the quantum variation of the other terms. For the required gradient is spacelike; for it is timelike in the Lorentzian target theory. Such backgrounds are not flat constant-dilaton Minkowski vacua with full target Lorentz symmetry, nor does a central charge cancellation by itself prove stability or unitarity of every noncritical background. If the conformal factor is instead retained dynamically, its Liouville field theory supplies the corresponding noncritical description.