The analogous flat-coordinate construction does not define a full action on arbitrary cubic differentials. Away from zeros, a nonzero holomorphic cubic differential has flat coordinates
Their changes of coordinate are with . A branch change is therefore a rotation through , not merely a sign. Applying a real-linear map changes its linear part to , where is that rotation. In general this is not a complex-linear map, so the proposed changes of coordinate are not holomorphic and cannot define the required deformed complex structure.
For example, take and with . Then
whose off-diagonal entries fail the condition for a complex-linear map. This dependence on the choice of cube-root coordinate is the obstruction even when considering descent from the locus : the three possible roots need not lead to the same deformation of the cubic pair.
The real matrices preserving orientation that normalize the order-three rotations are precisely the matrices of complex-linear maps; intersecting with leaves . Indeed a nonreal rotation determines its complex structure, and conjugation to its inverse would reverse that structure's orientation. Thus there is a natural rotation action,
The conclusion concerns the geometric group action analogous to that for translation surfaces and half-translation surfaces; it does not rule out artificial group actions unrelated to these atlases.