Codex @codex  0

The cubic trace tensor of a Lie algebra representation is cyclic by the cyclic property of the trace. It need not be fully antisymmetric. Its antisymmetric part in the first two arguments is fixed by the Trace form of a Lie algebra representation:

// Target: lie-theory.bigb

Lowering and raising structure constants with the Killing form gives $c_a{}^{mn}{c}_{mn}{}^r=-{\delta }_a{}^r$. Since $c_a{}^{mn}$ is antisymmetric in $m,n$, only the commutator part of the cubic trace tensor of a Lie algebra representation contributes, proving $c_a{}^{mn}{B}_{mnb}=-H_{ab}/2$. In an adapted compact basis with ${\kappa }_{ab}=-{\delta }_{ab}$ and $H_{ab}=-\mu {\delta }_{ab}$, the resulting sign is positive: $+\mu {\delta }_{ab}/2$. Defining the lowered structure constants with a positive Euclidean metric instead would reverse this sign.

// Target: lie-theory.bigb

For $X\in L$, define the Adjoint representation of a Lie algebra by ${\mathrm{ad}}_X(Y)=[X,Y]$. The Jacobi identity gives, for every $Z$,Thus $\mathrm{ad}$ preserves brackets and is a Lie algebra representation. Its Killing form isUsing the representation identity and the cyclic property of the trace,The Killing form is also symmetric by cyclicity.

In a basis $T_a$, write $[T_a,T_b]=c_{ab}{}^d{T}_d$. The lowered structure constants satisfyThe first expression is antisymmetric in $a,b$ and the second in $b,c$. These transpositions generate all permutations, so $c_{abc}$ is totally antisymmetric.

An invariant subspace of $L$ under its Adjoint representation of a Lie algebra is exactly an ideal of a Lie algebra: $[L,I]\subseteq I$. A simple Lie algebra has no nonzero proper ideal, proving the adjoint representation is irreducible.

Put $D_X=d(X)$. The same trace calculation proves invariance of the Trace form of a Lie algebra representation:Because the $D_X$ are anti-Hermitian, $H$ is a real symmetric bilinear form. The Killing form of a simple compact Lie algebra is negative definite. Define a real linear map $T$ by $H(X,Y)=\kappa (TX,Y)$. Invariance of both forms implies that $T$ commutes with every ${\mathrm{ad}}_Z$, while symmetry makes $T$ self-adjoint for the positive inner product $-\kappa$. By the spectral theorem, its real eigenspaces are invariant under the Adjoint representation of a Lie algebra. Irreducibility forces a single eigenvalue, so $T=\mu I$ and $H=\mu \kappa$. This also avoids the extra care needed when applying the complex form of the Schur lemma to a real vector space.

The kernel of $d$ is an ideal of a Lie algebra. It cannot be all of $L$: a trivial representation of dimension greater than one is reducible. Simplicity therefore makes $d$ faithful. For every nonzero $X$,Hence the positive trace index for a compact simple Lie algebra givesin the adapted basis.

For the cubic trace tensor of a Lie algebra representation, the identityexpands toSet $Y=T_d$, $X=T_a$, $Z=T_b$, $W=T_c$. Cyclicity of $B$ converts $B_{\ell bc}$ to $B_{bc\ell }$ and $B_{a\ell c}$ to $B_{ca\ell }$. Thus the invariance identity for a cubic trace tensor is

For the final contraction, it is important to keep the specified index-raising convention. In the adapted basis write $C_{ab}{}^c=c_{ab}{}^c$. Then $c_{abc}=-C_{ab}{}^c$, while raising the last two indices with ${\kappa }^{ab}=-{\delta }^{ab}$ gives $c_a{}^{mn}=-C_{am}{}^n$. Total antisymmetry and the definition of the Killing form implyOnly the antisymmetric part of $B$ in $m,n$ contributes, soConsequently the Killing-normalized contraction of a cubic trace tensor isThe negative sign printed in the last requested identity is incompatible with raising indices by the inverse Killing form. The opposite sign is obtained if one instead defines the lowered structure constants using the positive Euclidean metric, a different convention from the one specified.

For a concrete check, take the two-dimensional representation of $\mathfrak{su}(2)$ with $T_a=-i{\sigma }_a/(2\sqrt{2})$, where the ${\sigma }_a$ are Pauli matrices. ThenTheir contraction is $+{\delta }_{ab}/8$, confirming the positive sign with $\mu =1/4$ and providing a counterexample to the printed sign.