Angular-momentum estimate of a self-gravitating galactic disk Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-11-05
Let a disk contain fraction of its host mass and let its edge specific angular momentum be . With halo relation and disk geometry coefficient , combining centrifugal balance and the edge angular momentum gives the displayed estimates. The coefficient records the radial mass profile and thickness: enclosed mass does not determine a disc rotation curve. Treating as a monopole estimate must not be mistaken for an exact thin-disk theorem.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 59 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
For an axisymmetric Newtonian gravitational potential, the vacuum Laplace equation in cylindrical coordinates is . Use separation of variables, . Dividing by and setting the separated constant to , with , givesThe first equation has solutions ; with , the second is the order-zero Bessel differential equation. Regularity at the axis selects the Bessel function of the first kind , rather than the singular Bessel function of the second kind . ThusThere are also zero-separation-constant modes, and other boundary conditions can select other separated families. For a localized reflection-symmetric thin disk, decay away from the disk selects on the respective half-spaces.
Apply the divergence theorem to the Poisson equation for Newtonian gravity across a narrow pillbox enclosing disk area. Writing the volume mass density as givesReflection symmetry makes . A superposition of the regular vacuum modes therefore satisfiesThe order-zero Hankel transform and its inversion now determine the Hankel representation of thin-disk gravity:The sign is fixed by the positive derivative of an attractive Newtonian gravitational potential above the disk. For ordinary finite disks the representation uses the isolated boundary condition, fixing any extra vacuum field or additive constant. Infinite scale-free disks require suitable regularization of the potential itself.
Equatorial circular orbit balance is . Using in the Hankel representation of thin-disk gravity givesDifferentiation under the integral is justified by convergence for regular models, or by first working off the disk and taking the limiting radial field.
Write . For the Mestel disk, the supplied Bessel function integral gives for . The circular speed is thenMeanwhile the interior mass is . ConsequentlyThe Mestel disk has a flat galaxy rotation curve, despite its nonspherical geometry.
Its infinite total mass prevents setting the Newtonian gravitational potential to zero at infinity. Indeed the integral for diverges at because . Subtracting the potential at a reference point removes this additive divergence. As an explicit check, the Mestel disk potential-density pair isIt is harmonic for , its vertical derivative jump is , and . Equivalently, an Abel regularization of an oscillatory integral with damping factor in the radial-field integral gives , which tends to one as . The force is well-defined although the unreferenced potential is not.
The equality with is special to the Mestel disk, not a thin-disk shell theorem. The spherical shell theorem normally makes that formula possible, but does not apply to an astrophysical disk. Exterior annuli exert outward radial gravitational acceleration inside their radii, while interior annuli do not act exactly as point masses at the origin. For this particular scale-free surface density, their combined contributions happen to produce the same result as the interior mass expression. Changing the radial surface density or truncating the disk generally destroys the equality: enclosed mass does not determine a disc rotation curve.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 60 2 ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Take the retained disc mass to be the cosmic baryon fraction of the total dark matter halo mass: , where . Adopt and describe the disc gravity by . The structure coefficient must be stated: the scale-free Mestel disc gives when its flat rotation speed and enclosed mass are used, while a finite disc requires boundary and thickness information. The equality of edge specific angular momentum gives , with . Combining these relations gives the angular-momentum-conserving self-gravitating disc radius:With the commonly intended approximation,The corresponding masses are and , where is the solar mass.
For a definite formation estimate, assume the dark matter halo acquired this mass and radius at virial equilibrium, retained them afterward, and had mean density with . This uses the matter-dominated spherical-collapse model as an approximation to the specified matter-plus-vacuum cosmology. Since ,The approximate distance therefore gives formation modestly before observation. Using the numerical rather than approximate distance integral gives , within the accuracy of these structural assumptions. The calculation also assumes inclination-corrected spectroscopy, negligible disc pressure support, conserved edge specific angular momentum, no substantial later accretion or mergers, and no significant baryon loss.
This formation redshift is model-dependent, not uniquely fixed by the stated disc data. Keeping explicit gives . In particular, replacing the mean-density convention by times the critical density gives and , later than the observation. That inconsistent chronological result cannot be silently used as the formation epoch.
There is a further idealization in applying exactly at the edge: an abruptly truncated razor-thin disc with nonzero edge surface density of a disk has a logarithmically divergent in-plane force at that edge. Locally the available mass occupies a half-plane, and its radial contribution is proportional to , with no opposite exterior half-plane to cancel it. Finite thickness or a smooth taper removes that sharp-edge force singularity of a thin disk. Thus is an explicitly qualified Mestel disc or monopole-scale approximation, not an exact finite-disc calculation; enclosed mass does not determine a disc rotation curve.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 56 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
Let describe the halo and let . The cosmic baryon fraction is , so the specified settled fraction gives . The specific angular momentum constraint at the disk edge isTo infer an actual circular speed one must specify the disk's radial mass distribution: enclosed mass does not determine a disc rotation curve. Introduce a finite geometry coefficient by . A rounded, centrally concentrated disk permits a monopole estimate at its outer edge; it is an explicit approximation, not the spherical shell theorem applied exactly to a razor-thin disk. Ignore the force of the unsettled baryons as well as the dark matter within the disk. Using , the angular-momentum estimate of a self-gravitating galactic disk givesAn exact disk answer cannot be fixed by total disk mass alone; the dependence on records that missing input.
For the numerical virial radius of a dark-matter halo, adopt mean density times the critical density at the formation epoch. This conventional definition givesThe supplied expansion law gives , and hence . Taking yieldsThe corresponding virial mass of a dark-matter halo is , and . Other overdensity conventions give at fixed .
Interpret the wavelength separation as an observed-frame local mean near the redshift in question. Since Lyman-alpha absorption appears at , the incidence isAssume one counted absorption system per intercepted disk, no unrelated forest systems or missed absorbers, unity neutral covering fraction, and a locally slowly varying population. Let be the proper interception cross-section and the comoving number density. The proper density is , and the proper line element along the light path is . Thus the absorber incidence and comoving number density relation isFor a thin circular disk, the projected area is . Isotropically oriented normals have , so the random-orientation absorbing-disk cross-section is . ConsequentlyIf all disks are taken face-on instead, . Generally the random-orientation result scales as and is divided by the neutral covering fraction. The finite mean redshift spacing is sizable, so a precision inference would integrate the incidence over the actual redshift interval rather than identify it with one local value.
There is also a halo abundance mass-budget bound on this formal result. The present mean matter density for these parameters is . Distinct haloes of this mass cannot have , even if every matter particle belonged to them. Yet the inferred random-orientation population hasEven the face-on estimate exceeds this bound by about twenty-one. The numerical incidence result is conditional; the supplied population assumptions are not cosmologically consistent under this standard virial and compact-disk estimate. A larger neutral-gas absorption radius, a different absorber population, or different physical inputs are needed. For example, random orientations would require an absorbing radius at least about merely to reach the all-matter upper bound, much larger than the calculated centrifugal radius. This check does not change the algebraic answer, but prevents treating it as a realizable population.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2015 iii Paper 62 4 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For a spherical system, use the spherical shell theorem with shell mass . Inner shells contribute to the gravitational potential, while an outer shell contributes its constant interior potential . With , assuming the required integrals converge,On differentiation, the two terms containing cancel. Hence , where . Radial balance for a circular orbit gives .
For a razor-thin axisymmetric astrophysical disk, the element of mass is , where is the surface density. Superposing Newtonian gravitational potentials therefore givesAxisymmetry permits . Unlike the spherical case, an exterior annulus generally exerts a radial force: enclosed mass does not determine a disc rotation curve.
For the Legendre expansion of thin-disk gravity, split the radial integral at . In the inner part the kernel expands in , while in the outer part it expands in . The angular integrals of odd Legendre polynomials vanish, and those of even degree equal , whereIntroduce and . The gravitational potential becomesWhen differentiating each bracket, the moving-limit terms cancel: and . Since , this givesThe zeroth term has and . Separating it provesThe inner correction is inward, while the exterior correction is outward. For a smooth surface density, the original potential singularity at coincident points is integrable. Its radial force is understood through a symmetric Cauchy principal value or a vanishing-thickness regularization; the paired interior and exterior terms above retain the cancellation at . This avoids treating the two singular local force contributions separately.
For an exponential galactic disk, write , so and . At large , the missing mass and exterior-ring terms are exponentially small. The leading nonspherical interior term is , with and . Consequently the exponential-disk Keplerian asymptotic isThe positive leading correction shows that the rotation curve approaches the Keplerian limit from above. The finite-order large-radius expansion is sufficient here; an infinite moment expansion need not converge for a disk extending to infinity.
A useful special example is the Mestel disk, with surface density for , . It has . For every positive even ,All the nonspherical corrections cancel, givingThus the Mestel disk has a perfectly flat galaxy rotation curve.
This example has infinite total mass and a singular central surface density. The absolute gravitational potential cannot be set to zero at infinity, but the radial force exists as a limit of disks with increasing outer cutoff. Potential differences are . The earlier potential integral is therefore interpreted up to a radius-independent divergent constant for this example; the force calculation remains valid. Truncating the Mestel disk gives a more physical finite system but changes the exact flat curve near its edges.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 iii Paper 320 4 e Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
False. The enclosed-mass formula is a consequence of the spherical shell theorem. In a spherical galaxy, exterior shells exert no radial force and interior mass acts as though concentrated at the centre, giving .
A razor-thin axisymmetric disc instead hasBoth interior and exterior annuli contribute to that derivative. Its geometry is not determined by .
A concrete counterexample compares a central point mass plus an exterior spherical shell with the same point mass plus a thin circular ring of mass and radius . Their enclosed-mass profiles are identical: inside , and outside. The interior gravitational force of an exterior thin ring follows by expanding its angularly averaged relative potential:For , the ring's acceleration is outward, , whereas the spherical shell's acceleration is zero. With large enough to retain circular orbits, the disc-side speed isA narrow smooth annulus gives the same distinction. This proves that enclosed mass does not determine a disc rotation curve, even when the mass profiles of the spherical and disc models agree.
