Covariance of two components of a compound Poisson sum Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-11-05
Let be independent of independent and identically distributed random variables with finite second moments. Conditioning on gives covariance and conditional expectations . Law of total covariance and yield the formula. For per-claim excess of loss reinsurance payouts and , it becomes . The insurer and reinsurer aggregates share their claim count and are generally dependent.
Equal expected recoveries from excess of loss and stop loss Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-11-05
For independent exponential claims of mean and a zero-based geometric count of parameter , excess of loss reinsurance at per-claim reinsurance retention has expected recovery . The zero-based geometric sum of exponential variables has tail , so aggregate stop loss reinsurance at reinsurance retention has expected recovery . Equating them gives the displayed reinsurance retention relation. This comparison concerns claim payouts, before any reinsurance premium is charged.
Geometric count under Bernoulli thinning Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-11-05
Independently retain each event of a zero-based geometric distribution count with probability . Conditional on the original count, the retained count is binomial, so its probability generating function is . This is again a zero-based geometric distribution, with success parameter and mean . In excess of loss reinsurance, is the probability that a claim exceeds the retention.
Mean residual life 2026-10-07
For a nonnegative random variable with finite expected value and , its mean residual life is the remaining conditional expected value after surviving past . The tail integral formula for moments gives . The exponential distribution has constant mean residual life, equal to its original mean. In excess of loss reinsurance, the total variance stationary condition for excess of loss sets a candidate retention equal to this quantity.
Let . Conditioning on gives
Where the moment-generating function is finite around zero, differentiating the cumulant-generating function gives
In particular and . These compound Poisson cumulants use raw claim moments. The first two formulas also follow by conditioning: and , so
This is the law of total variance. They therefore remain valid with finite first two moments even when no positive exponential moment exists.
Under per-claim excess of loss reinsurance, put and let be the positive part of the excess. The insurer and reinsurer totals are sums of these payments over the same Poisson distribution count. Write . Using the tail integral formula for moments on the tail probabilities of and gives
For example, after , and shifting by gives the reinsurer formula. The moment formulas are finite whenever the corresponding claim moments are finite.
For the specified Pareto distribution, with shape three and minimum ,
If , every claim exceeds the reinsurance retention. Therefore
If , the tail integrals instead give
Consequently the requested sum of variances is
On the first branch, ; it decreases until and then increases. On the second branch . For the minimum is unique; if , all variances are zero and every reinsurance retention minimizes them. Thus
The curve starts at , reaches this minimum, passes through with matching slope on both branches, and then increases concavely toward the horizontal asymptote . The variance-minimizing retention for shape-three Pareto claims is shown below.
Figure 1.
Sum of insurer and reinsurer aggregate variances for shape-three Pareto claims, minimized at retention three quarters of the minimum claim size
. Details.
The two aggregate payouts are dependent. Conditioning on the common count gives covariance , so for every reinsurance retention, as required by . The covariance of two components of a compound Poisson sum accounts for this distinction between a sum of variances and the variance of a sum.
There is a moment domain qualification for this heavy-tailed example. For every , , and moments of order also diverge. Thus its positive moment-generating function is not finite and higher finite cumulants cannot be obtained by differentiating around zero. Its mean and variance calculations above are valid by conditioning or by the first two right derivatives at zero of the Laplace transform of a nonnegative random variable.
Condition on the claim count, defining the empty sum to be zero. Independence gives . By the law of total expectation,
For nonnegative claims this also follows from Tonelli theorem; for signed claims finite and ensure integrability. Conditional independence likewise gives
This random-sum transform identity holds wherever the composed series is finite, or as an extended nonnegative expectation. It is not permission to use an algebraic continuation outside the convergence domain.
For the zero-based geometric distribution, summing the geometric series gives
The exponential distribution of mean has for . Therefore
The stricter bound is necessary: the geometric series requires . At and above that series diverges; at and above even one claim has an infinite transform. Thus the displayed rational expression represents the moment-generating function only on its stated domain.
Since all claims are strictly positive, exactly when , so . Splitting the transform gives
Uniqueness of the moment-generating function identifies a mixture distribution with a zero atom of weight and an exponential positive component of weight and rate . In particular,
The density integrates to , not one. One can also verify it directly: conditional on , the sum has Erlang distribution density . Multiplying by and summing over gives , the same density. This is the zero-based geometric sum of exponential variables.
Under excess of loss reinsurance, the ceded amount for each claim is , and the monthly reduction is their random sum. The tail integral formula for moments gives
Conditioning on again yields
The retained payment is ; it is generally not .
Under aggregate stop loss reinsurance, the reduction is . The aggregate tail is for , so
The prefactor is positive. Equality with the per-claim recovery is equivalent to , giving the unique reinsurance retention
This is the relation for equal expected recoveries from excess of loss and stop loss; since , the aggregate reinsurance retention exceeds the individual reinsurance retention. These are reductions in claim payouts, before any reinsurance premium is deducted.
Under quota share reinsurance, the direct insurer retains a fixed fraction of each claim and the reinsurer pays the other fraction. Thus their annual claim totals are and . Under excess of loss reinsurance with retention , the direct insurer pays on each individual claim and the reinsurer pays . Under stop loss reinsurance with annual retention , the direct insurer pays and the reinsurer pays . The last two contracts differ because one caps each claim and the other caps the aggregate.
Conditioning on the annual Poisson distribution count gives the compound Poisson distribution transform:
This equality is understood on the domain where the moment-generating function is finite. By the expected value premium principle, annual premium income is . Without reinsurance, final capital is , and therefore
For the quota-share contract, the reinsurer's expected claim cost is , so its annual premium is
The direct insurer keeps its original premium income, pays this reinsurance premium and retains only . Thus
and
The reinsurer's loading is applied to the ceded expected loss, not to the direct insurer's original premium.
Maximizing expected exponential utility is equivalent to minimizing the exponent . For exponential distribution claim sizes of mean ,
so on the finite-utility domain ,
For a nontrivial positive arrival rate, differentiation gives
The unique unconstrained stationary retention is therefore
It is positive and lies below . If , it is the unique optimal retention in the printed range . If , expected utility increases throughout that open interval and its supremum is approached as ; there is no attained maximum in the strictly open range. Allowing the usual no-reinsurance endpoint gives the compact formula
Retentions with have infinite exponential loss moment and expected utility , so they cannot displace the finite stationary solution. The stationary point and full-retention endpoint just described stay within the finite-transform domain whenever they are selected.
For the requested comparisons,
Higher reinsurer loading increases optimal retention, up to full retention: reinsurance is more expensive. The direct insurer's loading does not affect the optimizer. It adds only the constant to , reflecting the translation property of constant absolute risk aversion. These observations give the quota-share retention under exponential utility rule; and the positive arrival rate also drop out of the stationary equation. In the degenerate case , no claims or premiums occur, , and every retained fraction has the same expected utility.
For excess of loss reinsurance with retention , the direct insurer caps its payment at and the reinsurer pays the excess. Thus
Let and . These are independent Bernoulli random variables, independent of . Since , its conditional law given is a binomial distribution. Conditioning on therefore gives the Bernoulli thinning identity
Here the probability generating function may be evaluated on , and the identity extends wherever the transforms converge.
The positive reinsurer marks have the conditional law . Hence
The independent-mark representation is justified as follows. Conditional on any fixed count and pattern of exceedance indicators, the positive excesses are independent with this same conditional law; that law depends neither on the number of exceedances nor on their locations. Averaging over the indicator pattern thus leaves the positive mark sequence independent of . We may extend it by additional independent copies if needed, giving with the stated independence.
Now write . For exponential distribution claim sizes of mean ,
Thus is exponential with the original mean , by memorylessness of the exponential distribution. The original zero-based geometric distribution count has . Consequently
This is the geometric count under Bernoulli thinning, with
Finally use the Laplace transform of a nonnegative random variable, keeping the mass at zero. For ,
The last expression is the transform of a mixture distribution: mass at zero and, with probability , an exponential distribution of rate . Uniqueness of the Laplace transform identifies this zero-based geometric sum of exponential variables:
Equivalently, and its positive density is . Therefore the requested exceedance probability is
The prefactor is essential: the aggregate is zero whenever no claim crosses the retention.
Set . The compound Poisson distribution variance identity and the per-claim excess of loss reinsurance payouts give
Apply differentiation under the integral sign. The endpoint terms in the first two terms cancel, while the last integrand is zero at its lower endpoint. Equivalently, differentiate the two payout squares inside their expected values; the finite second moment supplies a dominating integrable function. This gives the total variance stationary condition for excess of loss
Hence the specified equality makes . When , its interpretation is , where the mean residual life is .
For the exponential distribution of mean , and
Thus is negative below and positive above it. The variance-minimizing exponential retention is the unique global minimizer
For an explicit value, put . The capped claim moments and the excess-claim second moment give
The sign argument establishes global minimality, rather than just stationarity.
For a single claim , quota share reinsurance with retained fraction makes the direct insurer pay and the reinsurer pay . Under excess of loss reinsurance with retention , the direct insurer pays and the reinsurer pays the positive part . Thus the concise payout pairs are
The cap in excess of loss reinsurance applies separately to every claim; it is not a cap on the entire annual aggregate.
For the following variance calculations take and , so the displayed variances are finite. For any per-claim payout , the law of total variance in a compound Poisson distribution gives
The final term is the raw second moment, not the single-claim variance. Both parties' totals are retained compound Poisson aggregates, with different payout functions of the same claims; they are generally dependent.
For excess of loss reinsurance the insurer pays each claim up to its retention level:
The cap applies separately to every claim. In particular the retained annual loss is , rather than a single cap on the annual total.
Let be the cumulative distribution function for the claim size on risk , and put . The retained severity on that risk has the original probability density function on and an atom of a measure at of mass . Thus has a compound Poisson distribution with rate and the mixture of these capped severity laws. The mixture's mass at is .
For the capped claim moments, use the tail integral formula for moments. Since for and is zero for ,
Substitution into the compound Poisson distribution moment formulas gives
Equivalently, the integrals are and . The annual variance uses the retained raw second moments; subtracting their squared means would omit the variation in the Poisson distribution count.
Reinsurance retention 2026-10-14
A threshold limiting the insurer's retained payment under a reinsurance contract. Under excess of loss reinsurance it applies to each claim size; under aggregate stop loss reinsurance it applies to the total loss over the stated period. These contracts therefore cap different quantities even when their thresholds have the same numerical value.
Total variance stationary condition for excess of loss Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-11-05
For positive claim sizes with finite second moment in a compound Poisson distribution aggregate of parameter , the two excess of loss reinsurance payouts are and . The derivative of their total aggregate variance is . Thus the displayed condition characterizes stationarity. When the tail probability is positive it says that the retention equals the mean residual life. Global minimality requires an additional sign or comparison argument.
Variance-minimizing exponential retention Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-11-05
For exponential distribution claims of mean and compound Poisson distribution count parameter , the total party variance under excess of loss reinsurance is . Its derivative is , so is the unique global minimum, with value .