Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 iii Paper 13 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
A Freiman 2-isomorphism between subsets of abelian groups is a bijection such thatBoth directions matter: an injective homomorphism on individual elements may still create new pair-sum relations. More generally a Freiman s-isomorphism preserves equalities of sums of elements in both directions. For a nonempty finite set, its doubling constant is . A Freiman 2-isomorphism preserves this constant, since is a well-defined bijection of the two sumsets.
First let have elements and doubling at most . The permitted Plünnecke-Ruzsa inequality gives . We will obtain the half-size prime cyclic Freiman model for every prime . Choose an auxiliary prime larger than the absolute value of every member of . Such a prime exists: for any integer bound , every prime divisor of exceeds .
Choose uniformly from the nonzero residues modulo . For each nonzero , the residue is uniform among the nonzero residues. PutThere are at most such residues, and therefore the probability that any of the nonzero differences is dilated into is at mostThe first cardinal estimate is an upper bound even if some listed residues coincide; the slightly looser probability bound is convenient. Thus there exists with no such bad difference.
For this , let represent . Split these representatives into the two intervals and . Take from the more populated interval, so . For any four elements of , put . Their common half-interval gives , andIf the original difference is zero, then is a multiple of of absolute value less than , so . If the original difference is nonzero, is nonzero, and it cannot be a multiple of : otherwise its residue belongs to , contrary to the choice of . Therefore preserves pair-sum relations in both directions. It is injective as well, by applying the relation test to with any fixed . HenceThis proves the stated polynomial bound, including the prescribed prime rather than just an unspecified cyclic modulus.
Now let . Finiteness of places it in some finite-dimensional coordinate space, so models exist. Choose a Freiman 2-isomorphism with minimal. The doubling constant of is at most .
If a nonzero did not belong to , projection onto would preserve all pair-sum relations in both directions: a new relation would have original difference , whereas in characteristic two every such difference lies in . Projection is also injective on , since by adding any element of twice. This would give a model in dimension , contradicting minimality. Consequently every nonzero vector belongs to ; zero belongs as well, by adding one element four times. Thus .
Using the Plünnecke-Ruzsa inequality once more givesThis is the minimal binary Freiman models have full fourfold sumset argument. It also covers a singleton, with .