Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2005 ia Paper 1 11E Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
To prove the required zero-existence statement directly, let and . This set is nonempty and bounded. Continuity and the strict signs at the endpoints give a right neighbourhood of with negative values and a left neighbourhood of with positive values; consequently . If , continuity would give points of to the right of , contradicting its upper-bound property. If , continuity would give an interval immediately to the left of containing no points of , contradicting the approximation property of its supremum. Hence for some , proving this form of the intermediate value theorem.
For the half-interval claim, put on . It is a continuous function andIf either endpoint value is zero, it supplies the answer. Otherwise the signs are opposite, so the intermediate value theorem, applied also to if necessary, gives an interior zero. Thus for some .
For general positive integer , define on . At its grid points,If a sampled value is zero, it is the desired point. If none is zero, not all sampled values can have the same sign, so two have opposite signs; continuity gives a zero between their grid points. This proves the horizontal chord of reciprocal-integer length:For the interval is the single point zero, which works by the endpoint equality itself. The proof does not require a differentiable function or a periodic extension.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2015 ia Paper 1 11D ii Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-06
For a chord of length , consider the continuous function on . Since ,An endpoint zero already supplies the chord. Otherwise the endpoint values have opposite signs, so the intermediate value theorem supplies at some . Thus a horizontal chord of length exists.
For each integer , define on . The sampled differences telescope:If any sampled value is zero, it gives the required chord. Otherwise there must be both a positive and a negative sampled value. The intermediate value theorem, applied between their sample points, then gives . Hence a horizontal chord of length exists for every positive integer ; for , the endpoint chord itself suffices. This proves the horizontal chord of reciprocal-integer length result, without restricting to powers of two.
An explicit piecewise linear function isThe adjacent formulas agree at and , so the function is continuous, and . Any pair of points at distance can be written with . For every such ,Thus their values are never equal. The horizontal chord of reciprocal-integer length conclusion does not extend to this distance.
For , choose , . For , define the continuous functionIts values at the grid points have the telescoping sumIf one summand is zero, we already have a zero of . Otherwise the summands cannot all have the same sign, so two of these values have opposite signs. The intermediate value theorem between their arguments gives with . Set , . ThenThis is the horizontal chord of reciprocal-integer length property; the telescoping sum explains why reciprocal integers appear.