Use the instantaneous recycling approximation and treat the interstellar medium as well mixed. If star formation initially consumes mass , returning a fraction leaves locked stellar mass . The original metal mass removed from the interstellar medium is . Of this original material, returns and remains in the galaxy. In addition, the stellar yield produces fresh metal mass , of which the retained part is . Therefore metal accounting gives
This is the retained-ejecta chemical evolution equation. It assumes that the same retention fraction applies to original and newly synthesized metals. Pristine galactic gas inflow can change without contributing to ; enriched galactic gas inflow would require an additional metal source. Here , and .
A star inherits the gas-phase metallicity at its birth. Suppose enrichment is monotone and a fixed initial mass function, with an appropriate surviving tracer selection, produces observable stars per unit locked mass. For two birth abundances , the relative count is
Thus is proportional to the cumulative metallicity distribution function; its derivative gives the differential metallicity distribution function. The normalized distribution after final locked mass is . For logarithmic abundances, the logarithmic metallicity distribution instead has .
The fixed initial mass function and survival selection matter: a mass distribution is not automatically the number distribution of every presently observable star. If enrichment is nonmonotone, add the contributions from all birth-time branches attaining that abundance, rather than using one inverse.
A newly formed stellar population inherits the current gas-phase metallicity. Eliminate time between locked-mass growth and enrichment:
For , integration from pristine gas gives and hence the closed-box metallicity distribution
To obtain numbers rather than mass, specify a fixed initial mass function and count a long-lived tracer population. Let be its number of surviving stars per unit locked stellar mass. At the final gas-phase metallicity ,
with zero density outside that interval. The cumulative count is within the interval, and the normalized metallicity distribution function is
These equations do not use : any positive star formation rate gives the same distribution under the same chemical assumptions. If the tracer number is instead normalized per gross formed mass, replace by that normalization divided by . Short-lived stars require an age-dependent survival factor and generally do not follow this number distribution. In a logarithmic metallicity distribution, ; its interior peak is at , whereas the distribution per linear interval decreases from .
For , the gas-phase metallicity relation reduces to . Elimination of from mass conservation gives
With a fixed initial mass function, let be the number of surviving low-mass tracer stars per unit formed stellar mass. Successive stars inherit the monotonically increasing gas-phase metallicity, so the cumulative and differential counts are respectively
where is the abundance at the epoch when star formation stops. Above the cumulative count is constant, and the differential count vanishes. In the complete gas-exhaustion limit, and , so the normalized metallicity distribution function is on ; at a finite stopping epoch it is . The distribution is flat in linear metallicity. A logarithmic metallicity distribution instead satisfies and is not flat.
The G-dwarf problem is the observed shortage of metal-poor, long-lived disc stars relative to a simple closed-box model of galactic chemical evolution. In the fully evolved comparison, the half-rate proportional-infall model of galactic chemical evolution lowers the low- fraction from to , and prevents the closed-box tail from extending to arbitrarily high stellar metallicity. It therefore reduces the relative weight of the earliest metal-poor generation and the very metal-rich tail.
This particular constant-proportional-infall model is an improvement, not a complete fit. It still forms a metal-poor population immediately from its initially pristine reservoir, with nonzero constant all the way down to zero, and predicts a broad linear distribution followed by an abrupt upper cutoff instead of a generally smooth, concentrated observed distribution. Comparison with observed abundance histograms must first use the same coordinate: its logarithmic metallicity distribution rises in proportion to up to that cutoff, rather than remaining flat in logarithmic bins. Local G-dwarf measurements exhibit a prominent logarithmic-abundance peak and a paucity of low-abundance stars; translating iron abundances into total also requires an abundance-ratio model. More realistic histories can vary the galactic gas inflow and star formation rate, allow recycling and delayed enrichment, and account for migration and selection of different stellar populations; simply tuning a constant stellar yield does not remove all these shape deficiencies.