For a scalar field with , Lagrangian and stress-energy tensor , the inequalities and imply the dominant energy condition for any gradient type. In a local Lorentz frame, and .
Lorentz frame Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-11-05
A Lorentz frame at a spacetime event is an orthonormal tangent basis with metric tensor . Frames with the same spatial orientation and the same future time orientation are related by proper orthochronous Lorentz transformations. A time-orientation choice alone still allows spatial reflections. Any such basis can be realized at the event by normal coordinates.
The gravitational variable and the fields held fixed in a variation must be specified. For bosonic matter a second-order metric tensor formulation is sufficient. For spinorial matter a vierbein and a spin connection are needed to define the local Lorentz representation and its covariant derivative. “Second order” refers to a connection already expressed through derivatives of the vierbein; “first order” treats that connection as an independent variable.
For a metric tensor, a scalar field and an Abelian gauge field, consider the Einstein-Hilbert action with matter,
Here and the connection in is Levi-Civita. The metric tensor variation uses and
Metric compatibility makes the last two terms a divergence. Thus
Stationarity for arbitrary compactly supported variations gives
Explicitly,
Scalar field and gauge-potential variations give and . Their equations imply stress-energy conservation, consistently with the contracted Bianchi identity. If the boundary metric tensor is fixed instead of using compactly supported variations, add the Gibbons–Hawking–York boundary term, , with the outward-normal orientation. Fixing the metric tensor alone does not otherwise remove the normal derivatives of its variation.
For spinorial matter, write and . In the second-order theory set before varying. A symmetrized Dirac action, in the same no-, mostly-plus convention as the earlier solutions, is
Varying and integrating by parts gives ; varying gives the adjoint equation. The spinor components held fixed in a gravitational variation are components in the Lorentz frame. Both and vary with the vierbein. The former gives the canonical stress, and integrating the spin-connection variation supplies its spin-current improvement. On the Dirac equations the resulting symmetric stress tensor is
The off-shell expression also contains ; this vanishes on the matter equations for the displayed symmetrized action. Treating the coordinate gamma matrices as fixed while varying the metric tensor would miss the displayed stress. Local Lorentz invariance removes the independent antisymmetric vierbein equation, leaving the symmetric Einstein field equations with this matter source.
In a first-order vierbein formulation, and an antisymmetric Lorentz connection are independent. Define
and use . The curvature form of a connection variation is . For the Einstein-Hilbert term, integration by parts in form notation gives a connection equation proportional to
when matter has no connection dependence. For an invertible vierbein this forces , so . The vierbein equation then becomes the second-order Einstein field equations. This applies to the scalar and Maxwell examples: use , which is independent of and remains gauge invariant even if torsion is present.
A Dirac field changes the connection equation. Directly varying its two covariant derivatives gives
Thus its spin density sources totally antisymmetric torsion. This is Einstein-Cartan theory, and the connection equation is algebraic rather than a propagation equation for an extra field. To see both its solution and its effect, write
For the totally antisymmetric component sourced by this field, the Ricci scalar is up to a divergence. The other irreducible contorsion components have no spinor source and their connection equations set them to zero. The auxiliary part of the Lagrangian is therefore
Its algebraic variation gives the algebraic torsion of a Dirac field,
Here the first index of labels the derivative, and the torsion convention is ; specifying this convention fixes the sign. Eliminating leaves the second-order effective action with contact interaction
It is a local axial-current four-fermion interaction. Hence first-order gravity with Dirac spin density is equivalent to torsion-free second-order gravity with this additional interaction. It is not equivalent to simply declaring the spin connection torsion-free and dropping the contact term. In the effective formulation the Einstein field equations have the stress tensor of the full effective matter action. Before eliminating the connection, the antisymmetric stress and its spin current are related by the local Lorentz Noether identity.
Finally, the 1.5-order formalism is a convenient way to vary this effective action. Let solve the algebraic connection equation and let . The chain rule gives
Thus vary as in first order, then insert the solved connection. One does not need to calculate the complicated induced connection variation. This procedure is justified by its connection equation, not by discarding that variation arbitrarily. In supergravity the gravitino sources a contorsion quadratic in fermions; substituting it generates the four-fermion terms, while the 1.5-order method simplifies the local supersymmetry cancellation through the lower orders considered above.
For the P(X, phi) scalar field theory specialized to , vary the inverse metric tensor while holding fixed. With ,
Using yields
In any local Lorentz frame, set , , , and . Then
A direct calculation gives
Hence in every local Lorentz frame, proving the dominant energy condition. This proof covers timelike, null, spacelike, and zero alike; it does not assume or use a perfect fluid in general relativity rest frame. The hypotheses need only hold at every attained value of ; the stated all- assumptions are sufficient. For example, , , satisfies them.
In an orthonormal frame, and . The electromagnetic stress-energy tensor gives
The sign of follows directly from . Thus
and . These formulas hold in every local Lorentz frame, so the criterion just proved establishes the dominant energy condition. Equality occurs for a nonzero null Maxwell field with and , whose energy current is null vector.
Use the Minkowski metric with signature and write , . Future-pointing timelike means and . Thus
so is again future-pointing timelike.
Let and . In a Lorentz frame where , the future-pointing vector has . Consequently , with equality exactly when has no spatial component in that frame. Hence
Taking positive square roots proves
Equality holds exactly when are positive scalar multiples of each other. This is the reverse triangle inequality for future timelike vectors, not the Euclidean triangle inequality.
To prove the vanishing component theorem for a Lorentz four-vector, first suppose in every inertial frame. An infinitesimal boost along spatial direction gives . It too vanishes for every , so each . If instead a specified spatial component vanishes in every frame, spatial rotations first imply that all three spatial components vanish in a chosen frame, and a boost in the specified direction then forces . Therefore
A physical consequence is that conservation of energy in every inertial frame implies full four-momentum conservation: apply the result to the difference between outgoing and incoming total four-momenta.
The statement fails for general tensors. A nonzero antisymmetric rank-two tensor has in every frame, because antisymmetry is preserved. For an off-diagonal component, the nonzero Minkowski metric is another counterexample: in all orthonormal Lorentz frames, while is certainly not zero. The transformation law can preserve structural zero components without forcing the entire tensor to vanish.
If a fixed component of a Lorentz four-vector vanishes in every Lorentz frame, the vector is zero. For its time component, arbitrary infinitesimal boosts force every spatial component to vanish; for a spatial component, first use rotations and then a boost. Applied to the incoming-minus-outgoing total four-momentum, this shows that energy balance in every inertial frame implies full four-momentum conservation. The statement fails for general tensors: a nonzero antisymmetric tensor has zero diagonal components in all frames.