Past exam of the commutative algebra course of the University of Oxford 2017 2 c Solution 2026-10-25
Fix and suppose, for a contradiction, that . Set . Since is a Noetherian ring, this ideal is a finitely generated module, say . It is nonzero: if , then because is an integral domain.
The equality allows us to writeLet and . Then . The adjugate matrix identity implies that annihilates every . In the determinant expansion of , the constant term is and every other term contains an entry of , soThis is the determinant trick. Since some , multiplicative cancellation in an integral domain gives . But then , contradicting . We have proved the strict descent of powers of a nonzero proper ideal in a Noetherian domain:All these powers of an ideal have the same radical of an ideal. Indeed, gives . Conversely, if , then , so . Thusand gives infinitely many distinct ideals with the prescribed radical of an ideal. If the convention is used, the additional inequality follows immediately from properness.
Past exam of the commutative algebra course of the University of Oxford 2017 3 a Solution 2026-10-25
The Krull dimension of a commutative ring isThe length of a prime chain counts strict inclusions, rather than the number of prime ideals.
Let be a principal ideal domain that is not a field. We first show that every nonzero prime ideal is a maximal ideal. Write such a prime ideal as with , and suppose . Then for some . Since , either , in which case , or . In the second case for some , and gives by multiplicative cancellation in an integral domain. Thus . This proves maximality.
Since is an integral domain, is a prime ideal, and every other prime ideal is maximal. Consequently every prime chain has length at most one. For the opposite inequality, choose a nonzero nonunit , which exists because is not a field. The proper principal ideal is contained in a maximal ideal ; existence follows from Zorn's lemma applied to the proper ideals containing . A maximal ideal is a prime ideal, since its quotient ring is a field. Therefore is a prime chain of length one. Thus the Krull dimension of a principal ideal domain that is not a field is
Let be a Noetherian ring that is an integral domain, and let be a nonzero proper ideal. If for some , the nonzero finitely generated module satisfies . Choose generators and write with . The adjugate matrix identity implies that annihilates . This determinant is for some , since every term except the constant term contains an entry from .
The determinant trick has thus supplied . A nonzero element of and multiplicative cancellation in an integral domain force , contradicting properness of . Therefore all positive powers of an ideal are distinct in this setting. Since they have the same radical of an ideal, there are infinitely many ideals with radical .