Necessity of the root condition for multistep convergence

For a linear multistep method, convergence for every set of consistent starting values requires the root condition for a multistep method. Apply the recurrence to $y^{\prime }=0$ over $N$ steps. A root $\xi$ with $|\xi |>1$ gives the error mode $e_n=|\xi {|}^{-N}{\xi }^n$: its fixed-index starting errors vanish as $N\to \infty$, but $|e_N|=1$. A unit-modulus root of multiplicity $m\ge 2$ instead gives $e_n=N^{-(m-1)}{n}^{m-1}{\xi }^n$, with the same failure. Repeated roots inside the unit disk are harmless because their polynomial growth is dominated by exponential decay.