Past exam of the analytic topology and axiomatic set theory course of the University of Oxford / 2010 / B / 6 / a / Solution

The membership induction theorem is the following schema, for every formula $\phi (x)$ with any fixed set parameters:Its hypothesis says the property is progressive under membership. In ZF it follows from the Axiom of foundation: if a counterexample $x$ exists, take the nonempty set of counterexamples in the transitive closure $\mathrm{TC}(\{x\})$, which contains $x$. A membership-minimal counterexample supplied by the Axiom of foundation has no counterexample among its elements, contradicting progressivity. The transitive closure ensures that all elements relevant to this argument remain in the set being considered.