Past exam of the calculus of variations course of the University of Oxford / 2011 / 2 / b / ii

Here $I(0)=1/2$. First restrict $\Vert u^{\prime }{\Vert }_{\infty }\le \pi /12$. On that slope interval, the second derivative of $h(p)=1-\cos (\pi /3+p)$ is $\cos (\pi /3+p)\ge \cos (5\pi /12)>1/4$. Taylor's theorem givesThe linear term integrates to zero because ${\int }_0^1{u}^{\prime }=0$. Since $x^3\le 1$, the Poincaré inequality yieldsThe coefficient is positive. Thus zero is a strict weak local minimizer.

For failure of strong minimality, take a triangular bump supported on $[1/2-\epsilon ,1/2+\epsilon ]$, with slopes $+2\pi$ and $-2\pi$, and zero outside. Its height is $2\pi \epsilon \to 0$. Almost everywhere its slope is $0$ or $\pm 2\pi$, so the cosine term has exactly its zero-function value everywhere. The potential term is strictly negative on the bump. ThereforeHence it is not a strong local minimizer. The derivatives of these bumps stay large, so they do not contradict weak local minimality.