Past exam of the chemistry course of the year 1 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge / 2025 / 3 / c / ii / Solution

Basic methanol exchanges the ester alkoxy group while retaining the acetal; dilute aqueous acid removes the acetal while retaining the ethyl ester on the stated reaction timescale. An acetal lacks an electrophilic carbonyl and is stable to ordinary base: expelling methoxide directly would require a poor leaving group. The ester can instead undergo nucleophilic acyl substitution through a carbonyl-derived tetrahedral intermediate.

Under acid, protonating an acetal oxygen converts an alkoxy substituent into departing methanol, and the resulting oxocarbenium is stabilized by its remaining oxygen. Water then drives acetal hydrolysis toward the aldehyde. Ester hydrolysis is also possible under acid, but is slower under the conditions implied by the product data. The retained ethyl group and six distinct carbon-13 NMR environments support E rather than the carboxylic acid that prolonged hydrolysis could produce.