Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2002 / iii / Paper 33 / 4 / Solution

A measurement in quantum mechanics with outcomes $m$ is specified, in the single-operator-per-outcome description, by linear operators $M_m$ satisfying ${\sum }_m{M}_m^{†}{M}_m=I$. Its effects $F_m=M_m^{†}{M}_m$ form a positive operator-valued measure. The two measurement postulates are the Born rule for outcomes and the conditional state update:For a density operator the corresponding formulas are $p_m=\mathrm{Tr}(M_m\rho M_m^{†})$ and ${\rho }_m=M_m\rho M_m^{†}/p_m$. More general quantum instruments have multiple operators for each outcome and sum these terms. For a projective measurement of an observable $A={\sum }_m{a}_m{P}_m$, take $M_m=P_m$; the outcome value is $a_m$ and the postmeasurement state lies in its eigenspace. A POVM alone specifies probabilities, whereas the measurement operators or instrument also specify the backaction.

For quantum teleportation, Alice and Bob initially share the Bell pair $|{\Phi }^{+}{⟩}_{AB}=(|00⟩+|11⟩)/\sqrt{2}$. Alice also holds the input $|\psi {⟩}_C=\alpha |0⟩+\beta |1⟩$, with $|\alpha {|}^2+|\beta {|}^2=1$. The shared entanglement is a resource; the two transmitted classical bits alone could not transfer an arbitrary unknown quantum state.

Alice applies a controlled-NOT gate with $C$ as control and $A$ as target, then a Hadamard gate to $C$. Starting from $|\psi {⟩}_C|{\Phi }^{+}{⟩}_{AB}$, direct expansion givesFor example, the four receiver vectors are $\alpha |0⟩+\beta |1⟩$, $\beta |0⟩+\alpha |1⟩$, $\alpha |0⟩-\beta |1⟩$, and $-\beta |0⟩+\alpha |1⟩$. Thus the gate calculation fixes the ordering of the Pauli corrections, including the last branch's sign.

Alice measures $C,A$ in the computational basis, obtaining $(a,b)$. The Born rule gives each outcome probability $1/4$, independent of the input amplitudes. Bob's normalized conditional state is $X^b{Z}^a|\psi ⟩$. Alice sends the two outcome bits. Bob applies the inverse, $Z^a{X}^b$, and henceThe same circuit is a Bell-basis measurement on Alice's two qubits, expressed using ordinary gates followed by computational-basis measurements. It restores the state without Alice or Bob knowing $\alpha ,\beta$.

By linearity, the calculation also holds when the input is entangled with a reference: each outcome has branch map $|\psi ⟩\mapsto X^b{Z}^a|\psi ⟩/2$, and after correction every branch is one-half of the identity map. Summing the four corrected density operators gives exactly the original input density operator, with all reference correlations preserved. This is teleportation as an identity channel on a reference. Without the two classical bits Bob must average the four uncorrected states, giving $\frac{1}{4}{\sum }_{a,b}{X}^b{Z}^a\rho Z^a{X}^b=I/2$, so the process cannot signal before the message arrives. The Bell pair is consumed and Alice retains no copy of the unknown state, in accordance with the no-cloning theorem.