Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2003 / iii / Paper 46 / 1 / Solution

A phase diagram divides a space of control parameters into equilibrium thermodynamic phases, marking phase coexistence boundaries and thermodynamic critical points. Its dimension counts independently variable controls, not spatial dimensions. An explicit three-dimensional example uses the controls $(r,u,h)$ of a sextic even Landau potential:Here $M$ is a scalar order parameter, $h$ its conjugate field, and $r$ a thermal control. The equilibrium magnetization minimizes $V$ globally. At $h=0$, $u>0$, the boundary $r=0$ is a continuous phase transition. At $h=0$, $u<0$, the boundary $r=3u^2/(16v)$ is a first-order phase transition between $M=0$ and $M=\pm \sqrt{-3u/(4v)}$. The two boundaries meet at the tricritical point $r=u=h=0$. A fixed strictly positive quartic coupling alone cannot produce this tricritical point; the stabilizing sextic term is essential when the quartic coefficient is tuned through zero.

The full phase diagram also contains the $h=0$ phase coexistence sheet between positive and negative ordered phases. Crossing it changes the sign of $M$ discontinuously. For $u<0$, the three-phase line $r=3u^2/(16v)$ is the junction of this sheet and two tricritical wings, on which two unequal same-sign equilibrium magnetizations coexist at nonzero $h$. The tricritical wing critical edges are lines of ordinary thermodynamic critical points; they terminate the first-order sheets and meet at the tricritical point. Away from these boundaries, varying $h$ produces a smooth crossover.

For an explicit construction of the tricritical wings, write their two coexisting order parameters as $M_1=s-d$ and $M_2=s+d$, with $s>0$ and $0<d\le s$. Equality of their Landau free energies and first derivatives givesIndeed, for these controls the tricritical wing coexistence factorization isThe last factor is $(M+2s{)}^2+s^2-d^2\ge 0$, proving that both specified minima are global. The reflected wing has negative $h$ and negative $M$. Letting $d\to 0$ gives the tricritical wing critical edge $u=-10v{s}^2/3$, $r=5v{s}^4$, $h=8v{s}^5/3$; there $V^{\prime \prime }(s)=V^{\prime \prime \prime }(s)=0$ and $V^{\prime \prime \prime \prime }(s)=40v{s}^2>0$. Letting $d=s$ recovers the three-phase line. This supplies the first-order sheets and their continuous boundary curves, rather than only a zero-field section.