An inner model of ZF is a transitive class containing all ordinals and satisfying ZF with the inherited membership relation. The “all ordinals” requirement is important: an arbitrary transitive set model or a rank segment is not an inner model in this sense.
Every such inner model contains the ambient constructible universe . Here is the reason. Inductively . The zero stage is the same empty set. If the stages at agree, satisfaction for the common set structure is absolute: atomic first-order formulas agree, Boolean operations agree, and quantified variables range over the identical set. The codes of finite first-order formulas are also the same because a transitive model of ZF has the actual natural numbers. Consequently definability with parameters from produces exactly the same subsets in both models, so their successor constructible stages agree. At a limit ordinal both constructions take the union of the same earlier stages. This proves agreement at every stage and hence .
The constructible universe theorem provides models of ZF satisfying and the axiom of choice, whenever ZF is consistent. In such a universe any inner model of ZF satisfies
so and it also satisfies choice. Therefore
Passing to proves the consistency of choice, but the same downward method cannot prove its negation from an arbitrary starting model: it has no possible output when the starting universe is constructible. This is the precise obstruction intended in an inner-model independence argument. It is not a claim that every inner model of every choice universe satisfies choice; symmetric submodels of suitable forcing extensions can fail choice, and that method first changes the ambient universe.

Articles by others on the same topic (0)

There are currently no matching articles.